Two Philadelphia attorneys filed a lawsuit Friday in the state Supreme Court trying to force House Speaker Sam Smith, R-Punxsutawney, into scheduling special elections during the April 24 primary for a House seat in the South Hills and five other vacant districts statewide.

Former state Rep. Chelsa Wagner, D-Brookline, resigned from her 22nd District seat last month after being elected Allegheny County controller, but the seat has not yet been filled because of the chaos following new state House and Senate maps.

The district was to be moved to Lehigh County under maps drawn by GOP leaders in Harrisburg, but the maps were thrown out by the Supreme Court the last week of January.

Mr. Smith is following a state law, his spokesman said, that says seats may not be filled until a new redistricting plan is finally approved.

Advertise with us

That may take months, as new maps are not set to be unveiled until next week and, once approved, are expected to face several more weeks of public reviews.

"Speaker Smith is mindful of the impact this situation has on citizens who live in these vacant districts and the potential financial impact it has on the counties who clearly would prefer to hold the specials on the same date as the primary," spokesman Stephen Miskin said. "These concerns are clear and valid, but the law is equally clear in that he does not have authority to issue a writ until a final plan has the force of law."

The suit follows complaints from Democrats such as Allegheny County executive Rich Fitzgerald and House Minority Leader Frank Dermody, D-Oakmont, that leaving the seats unfilled is leaving residents unrepresented in Harrisburg. They also say holding the special elections on a date other than the scheduled April 24 primary will needlessly waste taxpayer money.

There is of course political calculus involved: four of the six seats are held by Democrats.

"Republicans are trying to disenfranchise voters by refusing to call special elections," the state's Democratic party chair Jim Burn said Friday.

Advertise with us

Special elections are typically trigged 10 days after seats are vacated, except in redistricting years. A bill approved in 2001 says the speaker may "delay the issuance of a writ of election until ten days after the date the final [reapportionment] plan attains the force of law."

Democrats argue the Republican speaker is not bound by that requirement and could move forward with special elections regardless.

Four Democrats and no Republicans filed Thursday to run for the empty 22nd District seat in the April 24 primary.