Peters police Chief Harry Fruecht Wednesday announced that he has ended an investigation into allegations that student athletes were "forced to play with injuries" and said he will take no further action.
"The police department has been unable to support these allegations with fact," Chief Fruecht said. "So we're done with it."
The department launched its inquiry last Thursday and interviewed at least nine people -- including six students, one parent, the school district's athletic director and an athletic trainer -- following a complaint forwarded by Washington County Children and Youth Services.
That complaint alleged that children were being allowed to play sports with concussions or concussion-like symptoms, according to the chief.
At the heart of the inquiry is the Peters Township School District's high school football program coached by Rich Piccinini.
Last week, Mark Mortland, whose company has a contract with the district to provide athletic trainers, publicly criticized Mr. Piccinini, claiming that he treated assistants and players poorly, interfered with the training staff and was dismissive of injuries.
Mr. Piccinini, 43, of Green Tree, disputed the allegations. His attorney, Robert G. Del Greco Jr., said after the news conference that his client -- who was not interviewed by police -- had been exonerated.
"I think this is a resounding exoneration of Rich Piccinini in all regards," Mr. Del Greco said. "When an investigation doesn't even reach the threshold where the target is invited to give a statement, there's nothing there."
Chief Fruecht refused to explain the scope of his investigation and declined to reveal many specifics.
"I don't want to go into every detail here because a lot of these are youths and they're protected," the chief said. "I think I've given you everything you need in regard to this matter. We haven't found anything new that warrants investigation."
District Superintendent Nina Zetty said the police investigation echoed the results of an internal probe conducted last year in response to concerns raised by Mr. Mortland in a Nov. 30 email to her.
Ms. Zetty released few details of the inquiry, such as how many students were interviewed and what they were asked, but said it was unnecessary to speak to every student athlete in the district's various sports programs.
"No, there was no need to. We investigated the allegations and found them to be false," Ms. Zetty said.
An oral presentation was made to the school board Jan. 17 about the inquiry, and written materials assembled during the investigation were sent to the police, Ms. Zetty said.
The district did not find any evidence that injured athletes were allowed back on the playing field without proper medical clearance, Ms. Zetty said.
Mr. Mortland, who served for 16 years as the Penguins' physical therapist and head athletic trainer, said the police department's findings were not surprising and are not germane to his accusations.
He said he never alleged that players were allowed back on the field without proper medical clearance.
"That's not even the issue," Mr. Mortland said. "Dr. Zetty's statement is correct, absolutely 100 percent. We never let someone go back in unless we had clearance from a doctor. But the fact of the matter is that has nothing to do with my letter."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.