Voters in Washington County elected a new district attorney, judge and county commissioner Tuesday, but two of the races still remained too close to call late yesterday.
Although Gene Vittone, the Republican candidate for district attorney, appeared to eke out a victory over his Democratic opponent Dave DiCarlo by just 165 votes, county election workers have yet to finish counting more than 1,100 absentee ballots, some of which were still arriving at county offices yesterday.
Workers began counting the absentee ballots yesterday afternoon and were hopeful that the count would be completed by today.
The absentee ballots may also affect the outcome of the four-way race for three open commissioners seats.
In that race, Democrat Harlan Shober held a tenuous lead of 386 votes against his GOP challenger, Bill Northrop.
Incumbent Commissioners Diana Irey Vaughan and Larry Maggi easily secured re-election, as did several county row officers who faced opposition, and President Judge Debbie O'Dell Seneca, who won a second 10-year term on the bench.
Before the absentee ballots were counted, unofficial results showed Mr. Vittone, 51, of Bentleyville, with 20,661 votes to 20,496 ballots cast for Mr. DiCarlo, 45, of Peters.
Mr. Shober, 66, a longtime supervisor in Chartiers, had 16,762 votes compared to Mr. Northrop, 52, a Peters businessman and newspaper publisher, who secured 16,376 votes.
The winner will replace current Democratic Commissioner J. Bracken Burns, who did not seek a fifth term.
Ms. Irey Vaughan, 49, a Nottingham Republican, won a fifth term with 20,552 votes, while Mr. Maggi, 61, a Democrat from Buffalo Township, won a third term with 23,111 votes -- more than any other candidate.
Mr. Shober said unusually high voter turnout of more than 41 percent in Peters, which is mostly Republican, skewed results in his election. The voter turnout rate countywide was about 31 percent, which is typical in a municipal election year.
More people voted in Peters due to a controversial referendum -- which failed by a large margin -- to ban Marcellus Shale gas well drilling.
Still, Mr. Shober thinks he is far enough ahead of Mr. Northrop to secure the win.
"I'd rather be ahead than behind right now," he said Wednesday. "I think it's over."
In the hotly contested race for a new Common Pleas Court judge to replace Judge Mark Mascara, who died last year, Democrat Gary Gilman defeated Republican nominee Lane Turturice, 37, of South Strabane, by 22,274 votes to 19,012 -- a margin wide enough to overcome any losses from the absentee ballot count.
Mr. Gilman, 49, of North Strabane, said being a long-distance runner for the past 28 years helped him withstand the rigors of the long and hard-fought race.
"That really helped me psychologically," said Mr. Gilman, who began campaigning 15 months ago and bested three challengers in the spring primary. "I realized this was going to be a long race."
A master and hearing officer for the Allegheny County courts, Mr. Gilman, who is married to Washington County Common Pleas Judge Katherine Emery, said he felt exhilarated meeting some of the nearly 10,000 people he visited while campaigning.
"It feels great," he said Wednesday morning. "I'm running on four hours of sleep, but I've never felt so good."
Mr. Vittone credited what he hopes is a win to "a true grassroots effort," especially in the face of the well-organized and heavily funded campaign orchestrated by Mr. DiCarlo.
"I'm still kind of numb," Mr. Vittone said Wednesday. "I keep telling people that I'm just a regular guy. I've been in public service for 30 years, so I didn't have a lot of money to draw from."
A longtime assistant district attorney who left the office earlier this year to concentrate on campaigning, Mr. Vittone also said he believes the popularity of current District Attorney Steven Toprani helped him secure more votes.
"Steve was instrumental in helping me in the [Mon Valley]," he said. "We're going to build on what he started."
Mr. Toprani decided not to seek a second term in office after crushing longtime District Attorney John Pettit in a contentious race four years ago.
No matter how the results shake out, Mr. Vittone and Mr. Shober said they felt proud about the positive nature of their campaigns.
"We kept our campaign positive," Mr. Shober said. "I'm very proud of everybody who was involved in this, including my opponent and my team."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.