Although the referendum to ban Marcellus Shale gas well drilling in Peters was resoundingly snuffed out by voters Tuesday, activists and members of a citizens group who fought hard for the ban said they were not disappointed by the result.
"Everyone was jubilant because all we were trying to do was to make people aware of this," said activist Jet Miskis. "We weren't really disappointed."
Voters in Washington County's most populous municipality were asked whether to ban gas well drilling and establish a "bill of rights" for residents that would guarantee the right to clear water and air.
A massive response from township leaders and industry groups succeeded in putting a halt to the referendum, which failed by a vote of 5,196 to 1,105, according to unofficial results.
The referendum garnered attention from the national media as one of the first opportunities for voters to exercise their opinions about whether natural gas well drilling -- and hydraulic fracturing, or "fracking" -- should be allowed in their neighborhoods.
A similar measure in the city of Warren, Warren County, also was defeated at the ballot box Tuesday, though one in the borough of State College, in Centre County, was approved.
A citizens group called Peters Township Marcellus Shale Awareness was responsible for placing the question on the ballot after gathering more than 2,400 signatures from Peters residents earlier this year.
Members of the group said they were concerned about health and safety, along with property values, if gas well drilling were to be permitted in the mostly residential township of 21,000 residents.
If the referendum had passed, it would have overridden an ordinance approved by Peters council this summer, which limited drilling to sites of at least 40 acres, along with other restrictions.
In the weeks and months leading up to the election, council members and industry groups spent thousands of dollars in court and through direct mailings, urging residents to defeat the referendum.
Council mounted an unsuccessful court challenge to have the question removed from the ballot because members felt it violated the state's Oil and Gas Act, the law governing most aspects of drilling.
Sue Smith, a member of the group trying to ban drilling, said there was little chance to succeed against the deep pockets of industry groups and local government.
"Town council has taken ownership of this now," she said. "It's their problem."
Council members believed their ordinance went as far as it legally could to regulate gas well drilling and members felt a ban would have been indefensible in court, possibly costing taxpayers millions of dollars had it been challenged by drilling companies who hold Marcellus leases with 774 property owners.
And now, the issue has been further complicated by the state Legislature, which is considering a move to quash all local regulations governing shale drilling in favor of statewide rules.
Councilman David Ball said he and other council members have begun lobbying state representatives hoping to stave off any changes that would limit the rights of local property owners.
"That's going to be the next step," he said.
Though no drilling has taken place, nor have permits been issued in Peters, drill sites are numerous in neighboring municipalities. Several large properties in Peters, including farms, cemeteries and golf courses, have signed leases and meet the requirements of council's ordinance.
It's a concern for group members who met briefly Tuesday night to discuss their next step, Ms. Smith said. Members will meet again soon to determine whether they should continue outreach efforts.
"I guess we're all disheartened," she said. "But, we are going to regroup."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.