This year's countywide races in Washington County promise to focus on the two issues that voters say are most important to them: drilling in the Marcellus Shale and possible property reassessments.
One expert, however, said voters may find it difficult to see much of a contrast among candidates.
"What is most interesting about this election is that no one is talking about it," said Joseph DiSarro, chairman of the political science department at Washington & Jefferson College.
While limited information is available regarding the positions of judicial candidates, the commissioners race has been active, and the contest for a new district attorney pits two men with distinctly different styles against each other.
"That could be an interesting race, but it depends on turnout," Mr. DiSarro said of the district attorney contest. "I think turnout will be less than 30 percent."
District attorney
The race is between two of Mr. DiSarro's former college students, Republican candidate Gene Vittone, 51, of Bentleyville, and Democrat Dave DiCarlo, 45, of Peters.
Both men have previously served as assistant district attorneys. The current district attorney, Steven Toprani, has said he won't seek a second term.
Mr. DiSarro said that Mr. DiCarlo has organized a well-funded, sophisticated campaign, while Mr. Vittone has strong community connections and could garner much grass-roots support.
Mr. DiSarro said the national mood is leaning toward Republicans, who also tend to do better in law-and-order elections.
Still, "it will depend on who can run a better campaign," he said.
Judges
While turnout in municipal election years is often dismal compared with presidential elections, voter interest may be piqued by the controversy surrounding the current president judge.
In state Superior Court papers filed this year, President Judge Debbie O'Dell Seneca was accused by defense lawyer Noah Geary of tampering with court transcripts.
Judge O'Dell Seneca, 58, of Nottingham, is seeking her second, 10-year retention vote in the Nov. 8 general election. She is prohibited by judicial canons from commenting on the controversy, but her court reporter filed a defamation lawsuit against Mr. Geary, saying his claims are false.
Mr. Geary accused court reporter Toni Dinardo of altering transcripts from the October 2009 murder trial of his client, Gerald Szakal, at the behest of Judge O'Dell Seneca.
The judge's supporters say the accusations by Mr. Geary are politically motivated, but Mr. Geary maintains the controversy could be cleared up through audio tapes of the weeklong trial. The high court has so far denied his request for those records.
Although the issue is not likely to be resolved before the election, Mr. DiSarro said he thinks it's highly unlikely that the judge would lose an up or down retention vote based on Mr. Geary's accusations.
"I think the retention of the president judge is a foregone conclusion," he said. "It's just simply not enough to challenge her impeccable credentials. I don't see this as being anything other than a bump in the road for her."
Also generating interest in the local judiciary race is a new member who will be elected this year.
Democrat Gary Gilman, 49, a North Strabane lawyer, and GOP candidate Lane Turturice, 37, a lawyer from South Strabane, will compete for a judicial seat left vacant last year with the death of Judge Mark Mascara.
County commissioners
Facing off for three available commissioners seats will be two candidates from each party: Democratic incumbent Larry Maggi, 61, of Buffalo; Democratic challenger Harlan Shober, 66, a longtime supervisor in Chartiers; Republican incumbent Diana Irey Vaughan, 49, of Nottingham; Republican challenger Bill Northrop, 52, a Peters businessman and newspaper publisher.
Current Commissioner J. Bracken Burns announced earlier this year that he would not seek a fifth term. Ms. Irey Vaughan is seeking her fifth term, while Mr. Maggi is pursuing his third.
The candidates are expected to square off Oct. 17 in a debate sponsored by the League of Women Voters of Washington County at the Olin Fine Arts Center at Washington & Jefferson College.
During the spring primary election season, candidates said that as they traveled the county -- which has become a hot spot of Marcellus Shale drilling activity in southwestern Pennsylvania in recent years -- they heard from voters who were concerned about everything concerning the shale, from local fees and damaged roads to water quality and the safety of hydraulic fracturing or fracking.
While the state has so far not passed a natural gas extraction tax, communities that have been hit hard by expenses from gas wells being dug in their part of the shale are struggling for ways to recoup costs and enforce local ordinances.
Other than bringing pressure on state lawmakers and helping to educate the public, candidates said there's little the county can do to resolve financial or environmental issues involving gas drilling.
Among the other concerns facing the next board of commissioners is a court-ordered, countywide property reassessment.
"Are those issues that could turn the tide? Possibly," said Mr. DiSarro. "But, I don't think the candidates differ much on these issues."
In a county with a 1.4 to 1 Democratic voter registration edge, Mr. DiSarro said he expects Democrats will probably fare better in November, though in the past two presidential elections, local voters have gone with Republican nominees.
A higher-than-anticipated voter turnout might also produce some unexpected results, he said.
"Turnout, turnout, turnout," he said. "It might help somebody who is a little less known."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.