Though voter turnout was predictably low -- about 20 percent in Washington and Allegheny counties -- Tuesday's rainy-day election held some surprises.

In Washington County, the controversy over a temporary Common Pleas Court appointment that was opposed by the local and state legal community also apparently didn't sit well with voters.

Primary election results

Below are links to local county websites and results from Tuesday's primary election:

Advertise with us

Though Judge Phil Melograne, 50, of Peters, was appointed by then-Gov. Ed Rendell in October to temporarily fill the judicial seat left vacant by the death last summer of Judge Mark Mascara, he couldn't persuade voters to give him a shot in the Nov. 8 general election.

The way his appointment was made left a sour taste in the mouth of the county bar association members and state Supreme Court Chief Justice Ronald Castille, who both opposed the appointment. Justice Castille objected to it for budgetary reasons, while bar association members said they were led to believe the seat wouldn't be filled temporarily.

Angry lawyers cried foul over what they saw as an unfair political appointment.

Each of the four judicial candidates cross-filed, including Judge Melograne, but he didn't win either nomination. On the Democratic side, North Strabane lawyer Gary Gilman, 48, ran away with an early and convincing victory for the Democratic nomination, according to unofficial results from the county election office.

Trailing Mr. Gilman for the Democratic nod was Judge Melograne and Canton lawyer Charles Kurowski, 59, a six-time judicial candidate, and South Strabane lawyer Lane Turturice.

Advertise with us

The GOP chose Mr. Turturice, 38, as its candidate, followed by Mr. Gilman, Judge Melograne and Mr. Kurowski.

Each party selects one candidate to compete in the general election.

A master and hearing officer for the Allegheny County courts, Mr. Gilman, who is married to Washington County Common Pleas Judge Katherine Emery, reported more than $100,000 in campaign spending and contributions -- more than any other candidate.

He also received more "highly recommended" votes than any other candidate among Washington County Bar Association members in a poll released earlier this month.

Mr. Turturice is best known as solicitor for several local governments. He used his campaign Facebook page on Tuesday night to thank supporters and post results.

Advertise with us

In the crowded race for nominations for Democratic county commissioner, incumbent Larry Maggi bested six other candidates, collecting 12,488 votes.

The hotly contested second Democratic nomination went to longtime Chartiers Supervisor Harlan Shober, though the 66-year-old was neck-and-neck most of Tuesday night with Washington city Councilman Joe Manning, 49.

Each party nominated two candidates, who will vie for three open seats in the general election. Current Democratic Commissioner J. Bracken Burns did not seek a fifth term.

The other Democratic candidates were Ellsworth lawyer John Petrisek, 40; Canonsburg labor leader Wayne E. Watson, 60; North Strabane Supervisor Greg Sulc, 42; and former Coal City Councilman Randy J. Barli, 56.

On the Republican ticket, candidates Diana Irey Vaughan, 48, of Nottingham, who is seeking her fifth term, and Bill Northrop, 52, a Peters businessman and local newspaper publisher, faced no challengers.