It's been only two weeks since state Sen. J. Barry Stout, D-Bentleyville, unexpectedly announced he would retire at the end of this year, but already the jockeying among Washington County politicians has begun for his 46th District seat.

As nominating petitions began circulating Tuesday, a number of potential candidates emerged, including all three county commissioners and local state Rep. Tim Solobay, D-Canonsburg, who said he will likely run for the Senate seat.

That, in turn, has created speculation about the 48th District state House seat, occupied by Mr. Solobay, who is up for re-election this year.

Suddenly, two coveted positions could be wide open, leading one political adviser to predict a "bloody battle" in the May 18 primary elections.

Advertise with us

"There are a lot of balls in the air and none of them have landed yet," said Democratic Commissioner J. Bracken Burns, who said he is considering a run for the state Senate or House or possibly even the 12th District Congressional seat formerly held by U.S. Rep. John Murtha, D-Johnstown, who died last week.

After a serious bout with pneumonia in 2004, Mr. Stout, 73, likened local politicians to "circling vultures" waiting for his retirement or death, saying "they'll take this office out of my cold, dead hands."

But he had a change of heart last week, saying that ongoing health issues and the lingering effects from an accident that fractured his pelvis would keep him from seeking another term after nearly 40 years in the state Legislature.

Mr. Stout was one of the most powerful members of the Senate, having served as leader of the Senate Transportation Committee, as Democratic Caucus administrator and as a member of numerous committees, such as those governing policy and appropriations.

How the county will replace the famous "Stout clout" in Harrisburg is an important consideration for strategists, who see Mr. Solobay and county Commissioners Larry Maggi and Diana Irey as the front-runners in the race.

Advertise with us

"We can't afford, in Southwestern Pennsylvania, to allow someone to go down there who doesn't even know where the bathrooms are," Mr. Solobay said of Harrisburg. "I think [my experience] weighs heavily on what we can offer."

Mr. Solobay, 53, said he brings 12 years of carefully cultivated relationships and resources to the table, along with what he hopes will be support and endorsements from several important political factions. He is circulating petitions for his House seat and for Mr. Stout's Senate seat, although he said he would not run for both positions.

"We are very actively pursuing it. We have petitions all over the region," he said of the Senate seat.

Ms. Irey, a Republican, said she is "absolutely" considering a run for the Senate seat, while Democrat Mr. Maggi said he is "thinking very seriously" about running and has also begun circulating petitions.

Mr. Maggi, 58, of Buffalo, serves as the chairman of commissioners and remains a respected and popular figure from his days as the county's budget-conscious sheriff and as a homicide investigator for the state police.

Advertise with us

He is currently serving his second term as commissioner, having garnered more votes than Mr. Burns or Ms. Irey in the past two elections. He made an ill-fated run for the 18th Congressional District seat held by Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, in 2002, but couldn't get past the primary.

Ms. Irey, 47, of Nottingham, fared better in her Congressional run against Mr. Murtha in 2006, snatching 42 percent of the vote against the popular incumbent.

In her fourth term as the only female commissioner ever elected, Ms. Irey is known as a fundraising machine, routinely raising double what her opponents have.

That skill would serve her well in a state Senate race, said Dr. Joseph DiSarro, chairman of the political science department at Washington & Jefferson College.

"My gut feeling is that Irey is going to be in," he said. "She is young, that district has changed and this is her last chance."

Advertise with us

He believes Ms. Irey would need to raise about $250,000 to defeat a Democratic candidate in the district, where the GOP is outnumbered by a nearly 2 to 1 margin.

Still, voters in the district, which includes most of Washington County, all of Greene County and parts of Beaver and Westmoreland counties, have been swaying more conservative in recent years, Dr. DiSarro said, with the majority voting for Arizona Sen. John McCain in the 2008 presidential election.

Dr. DiSarro said he wouldn't be surprised to see Ms. Irey tap some of her national fundraising sources and possibly even persuade well-known Republican women, like Sarah Palin and Minnesota Rep. Michelle Bachman, to appear on her behalf.

"I think you'll see some significant Republican women come in and help her," he said.

On the Democratic side, Dr. DiSarro predicts a major battle between Mr. Maggi and Mr. Solobay, known as a champion for firefighters, health care and emergency services in the state House.

Advertise with us

Mr. Solobay has not faced a serious challenger since his election in 1998. Dr. DiSarro said he thinks Mr. Solobay would have the strategic advantage.

"It will come down to a nuts and bolts campaign between two Democrats who are very similar," Dr. DiSarro said.

Potential candidates have until March 9 to submit nominating petitions to be placed on the primary ballot.