Soon, Amanda Smail-Carrizalez plans to pack up as much of her family’s belongings as she can, leave behind the home she and her husband bought and renovated in Butler, and move to Tamaulipas, Mexico with her 6-year-old daughter.

It’s not what she envisioned, but it's the only way Smail-Carrizalez, 43, a lifelong resident of Western Pennsylvania, believes she can keep her family together after her husband, Ignacio Carrizalez, was stopped April 28 by Evans City police as he drove to work.

She said her husband of more than 13 years — who was born in Mexico and has been in this country for more than two decades — was stopped for an apparent traffic violation, then police handed him over to ICE and he has been in immigration detention ever since.

Smail-Carrizalez has tried unsuccessfully to reach out to state and local lawmakers for help, leaving her with only one choice — to self-deport as a family.

Advertise with us

“We see that as the safest option,” she said.

On Wednesday, Smail-Carrizalez attended a Butler County Commission meeting to urge county leaders to consider ending their partnership with the federal government under what’s known as a 287(g) agreement, which allows ICE to deputize local police officers to conduct immigration enforcement.

The agreement Butler County Sheriff Michael Slupe signed with ICE in June 2025 has faced ongoing scrutiny from some residents who oppose the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown and the sheriff’s department’s participation in it.

Slupe told the Post-Gazette there have been between 50 and 70 immigration arrests made by local law enforcement in the county since he joined the program. In exchange, his department has received just under $200,000 from the federal government.

Smail-Carrizalez said the collaboration between local police and ICE has destroyed her family after the arrest of her husband, who she said has been paying taxes, has no criminal record and had documentation to live and work in the United States.

Advertise with us

“If I don’t say something, nobody will know,” she said. “Even though we’re choosing to self-deport, our story needs to be heard.”

She said the morning her husband was arrested began like any other until he called on his way to work to tell her that he had been stopped by police, who quickly summoned immigration authorities.

Smail-Carrizalez said she remained on the phone with her husband as he was arrested and pleaded with officers on the scene to allow her to provide his immigration paperwork.

“I was still on the phone when they surrounded him,” she said. “I could hear a commotion and my husband asked what was going on and I was on the phone trying to tell them I am an American citizen, he is married to me, and I will send over all his documentation to his phone … and one of the ICE officers said, ‘Looks like nobody’s helping you today,’ then click, the phone hung up.”

Smail-Carrizalez told Butler County commissioners that the month and a half since her husband’s arrest has been a nightmare as he remains detained in Moshannon Valley Processing Center, the largest ICE detention center in the Northeast, located near Philipsburg, Pa.

Advertise with us

She has struggled to find mental health services for herself. Her daughter, who has autism, does not understand why her father never returned home that day. Bills are going unpaid without the income her husband was bringing in.

“I can’t stay here without my husband,” she said. “He was the provider. My bills are piling up. Cable and garbage is already shut off. We can’t stay here without him. We bought a house in 2015 and renovated it. It is a beautiful home and that was all because of my husband. Now I’m being forced to give everything up.”

While addressing commissioners, Smail-Carrizalez broke down sobbing multiple times. Her hands shook as she clutched a binder filled with her husband’s immigration papers, which had a photo from their wedding attached to the front.

Her daughter, dressed in pink pajamas, stayed close beside her mother, her shoulder next to her mother’s hip as she spoke.

“We are American citizens and I feel like we’re being punished,” Smail-Carrizalez said. “No child should ever have to feel the way my daughter has been forced to feel.”

Advertise with us

Afterward, she asked her daughter if she wanted to say anything.

The girl whispered in her mother’s ear for a moment then looked up.

“We are going to Mexico,” the girl said.

Leslie Osche, chair of the board of commissioners, has long supported the sheriff’s partnership with ICE along with fellow Republican Commissioner Kimberly Geyer. She said it was not in the commission’s purview to end or alter the partnership in any way.

Even if the county commissioners unanimously requested the partnership be ended, Slupe told the Post-Gazette he would not do it.

Advertise with us

“At the end of the day, it’s still the law that’s being violated and, in this case, I don’t know the particulars,” he said. “I feel horrible for her and her family … but I don’t know the guy’s history, I know nothing about him.”

ICE did not respond to requests about Ignacio Carrizalez’s arrest and detention. Pennsylvania court records show no criminal record for him in the state.

Since last year, more than 100 law enforcement agencies across Pennsylvania have partnered with ICE through the 287(g) agreement.

Data compiled by the Deportation Data Project show ICE reported 244 arrests attributed to 287(g) partnerships across the state between July 2025 and March 2026.

About 67% of those arrested had no criminal record beyond an immigration violation, 14% had a criminal conviction on their record, and another 18% had pending charges at the time of their arrest, according to the data.

Advertise with us

About half of the $200,000 that the Butler County Sheriff’s Office received from the federal government has been earmarked for vehicles.

The remaining money is being used to pay for additional insurance the county needed to cover the costs of any lawsuits that arise from the 287(g) program, as well as buying additional equipment, including tasers, for officers.

The money comes as the county struggles with tight budget constraints, Slupe said.

“I wanted to buy tasers or other equipment, but I didn’t because the budget woes of the county were a lot,” he said. “So we don’t have to ask the county for that money next year.”

Slupe said he recently requested another $74,000 from the federal government for reimbursement for salaries and benefits for the deputies who have participated in the program.

Advertise with us

He also responded to criticism that has come from the community that the money the department is receiving for its involvement in the 287(g) program is ultimately coming from taxpayers.

“It’s taxpayer money, yes, we’re paying it,” he said. “My offer is, if we don’t get it, somebody else will. It’s available for us to use.”

Slupe said a case like the Carrizalez family’s — where the person who was detained is married to a U.S. citizen and the couple has a child — is the first he heard of in the county.

The sheriff attended Wednesday’s meeting and said he could not help but be moved by Smail-Carrizalez’s story.

“I feel bad for her situation,” he said. “We are all human, right? The unfortunate part is, I personally do not know the extent of the immigration law that was violated.”