When a chemical-carrying Norfolk Southern freight train derailed less than a mile from his East Palestine home, Josh Hickman was forced to live out of a Columbiana, Ohio, hotel for 415 days. When he and his family returned home, it was no longer the place they had left.

His homeowner’s insurance, not Norfolk, covered testing and extensive remediation on the property, where most of his furniture, carpet and personal belongings had to be tossed out and replaced.

“It was the hardest time of our lives,” Mr. Hickman said. “You live in a hotel for over a year, and you’re excited to get out of there. But then you wonder, like so many other residents, 'Is it really safe?' ”

With these lingering questions and no “real sense of accountability,” Mr. Hickman, along with hundreds of others, is taking Norfolk Southern and federal agencies to court with new litigation.

Advertise with us

The case, filed Jan. 31 by 744 current and former residents, accuses Norfolk Southern, the Environmental Protection Agency and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention of negligence in their response to the derailment. The lawsuit claims they failed to adequately test, clean up and protect the affected communities in Ohio and Pennsylvania. It also attributes the deaths of seven people to the derailment.

“Taxpayers and our families shouldn’t be forced to pay the real costs of this disaster, or the health and environmental consequences,” Mr. Hickman said. “That’s what this lawsuit is about. And that’s what the class suit should have been about.”

Last year, residents and businesses within a 20-mile radius of the derailment were eligible to submit claims for damages and losses in a $600 million settlement with Norfolk Southern. Over 55,000 claims were filed, but concerns over a rushed agreement have caused an appeal that is holding up the distribution of most payments.

Mr. Hickman said he was unable to opt in to that settlement due to an active insurance claim, but he had hesitations regardless.

“Everybody's experience was different,” he said. “They should have just been more individualized, as opposed to you getting a household payment in one person's name, and it's up to that person to divvy up the money.”

Advertise with us

Attorney Kristina Baehr is leading the new litigation effort, arguing that the $600 million agreement, while historic, did not provide sufficient relief. She is the founder of Just Well Law, an Austin-based legal firm specializing in environmental toxin cases.

“Bear in mind that it's only $400 million for the community,” she said. “You divide that by 55,000 and it's nothing. When you speed the process, you don't get truth and justice. The class action was not even half justice.”

Court documents in the new suit highlight a pattern of safety failures by Norfolk Southern, noting that the company’s crash rate surged by 81% between 2013 and 2022. Despite this, the class-action settlement amounts to less than a month of revenue — a fraction of what she and other residents say is needed to address the damage done.

“This was entirely preventable and predictable,” Ms. Baehr said. “If a railroad is entrusted with carrying chemicals through communities, it has to follow the safety rules. It has to make sure that there are sensors on those cars. It has to make sure that if the car starts sparking, you don't let it continue. But instead, they all prioritized profit.”

Ms. Baehr said this is not another class-action lawsuit. Rather, they are pursuing two legal actions: one against Norfolk Southern and local entities in the Ohio courts, and another against the federal government.

Advertise with us

Some residents involved in the new litigation are also part of the larger class action, but their involvement is limited to claims filed against the EPA and CDC.

For the first time, the suit brings deaths linked to the derailment into litigation. One case involves a 65-year-old man with pre-existing respiratory issues who suffered a sudden health decline after the derailment. Another case involves a 1-week-old infant diagnosed with a genetic conditions known as Trisomy 18, who died a week after birth.

According to the complaint, the CDC instructed medical professionals not to test for dioxins and other toxic chemicals following Norfolk Southern’s controversial decision to conduct a controlled burn of hazardous materials. Residents were “denied” accurate diagnoses and critical medical care as a result, the suit argues.

The lawsuit further claims the EPA’s inadequate oversight over the response prolonged exposure risks for residents who were told prematurely it was safe to go home, Ms. Baehr said.

“I've heard some concern about, ‘Oh, you're never going to be able to prove it,’ ” she said. “Well, it's not hard for a jury. It's just common sense. These people were poisoned at home.”

Advertise with us

With legal proceedings still in the early stages with no set court date, Ms. Baehr said this case is about more than seeking more compensation.

“What our clients are really looking for that prevention,” she said. “They want the EPA, the village, the railroad, next time this happens to do it differently.”

The legal team also requested a jury trial to give residents “their day in court,” Ms. Baehr said.

That’s what Mr. Hickman hopes for.

“There were just really too many questions to be answered,” he said. “There needs to be some accountability.”