The Adams Township board of supervisors voted unanimously to strike down a proposed ordinance that would allow authorities to fine farmers over animals that become a “public nuisance” after they were met with public outcry.
The vote came during a contentious board meeting Monday night where residents lined the municipal building meeting room and spilled out into the lobby.
The proposed bill came after numerous complaints were made by residents of the Brookhaven Community in Mars, a community of 35 homes, who said that livestock cattle, including bulls, were escaping from a nearby farm, causing property damage, endangering children and the elderly, and destroying landscaping.
There have been 30 complaints received in this year, with 10 of those complaints coming in November, according to township supervisors.
However, despite the complaints, community members, including numerous farmers, came out in force to Monday’s meeting to oppose the bill they said would do more harm than good.
Nearly 30 residents signed up to give testimony at the meeting and every person who ultimately addressed township supervisors opposed the ordinance, which would allow authorities to levy fines of up to $600 against farmers whose animals run at large, attack pedestrians or other animals, chase vehicles, trespass on private property, or defecate in a manner that affects community welfare.
Every person who testified in opposition of the ordinance was met with rousing applause.
“This law will do nothing to fix the root cause of the problem,“ Rob Crouthamel, a 50-year-old part-time farmer from Adams, said. “Instead, I feel this law could be used to pile on charges, fines and legal expenses for each day and offense on his farm, haul a farmer in front of the magistrate, place liens on the farmer’s land if he fails to show or pay. I don’t think this is how the residents of Adams want their farmers treated.”
Mary Snow, who runs the Snow on the Hill farm, and her daughter Daisy, the 2023-24 Butler County Dairy Princess, also testified against the ordinance.
“The biggest problem I have with the overreaching ordinance is that it takes away our own rights and responsibilities,” Mary Snow said.
Ms. Snow said numerous residents came to her amid the complaints stemming from the Brookhaven community to put together a plan to help the farmer whose livestock was escaping. Many people described the farmer as elderly during the meeting but did not mention him by name.
“A lot of people have reached out to personally help with that situation, so I urge you not to make another rule and another law that empowers other people to complain about the noise part especially,” Ms. Snow told supervisors. “That’s the biggest problem I have. Roosters cock-a-doodle-do. Cows in heat will moo continually for a week trying to get to the next cow. It’s annoying, but its nature and our roots around here are caused by that.”
Eventually, after about 45 minutes of testimony, supervisors went into a recess to make a decision.
When they returned, every supervisor voted to deny the ordinance.
The final vote was met with loud applause.
“I do think it’s a good decision,” Richard Rapp, 42, of Mars, said. “I do think we need to get together with the homeowner [who complained] and make amends. She’s not used to seeing cows.”
Others said they were glad the decision on the ordinance was made Monday after it was tabled at the previous supervisors meeting on Nov. 27.
“I’m very relieved that they decided the way the farmers thought it to go down,” Mr. Crouthamel said. “I’m glad they didn’t kick it into next year and keep the debate going. It just needed to end here.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.