If Wilkinsburg residents want to pursue annexation by the City of Pittsburgh, it must be approved through a referendum vote, a state court ruled Thursday. 

A Wilkinsburg community group sought to restart the annexation process last fall after it had been voted down by Pittsburgh City Council in February 2022. An opposing group, made up of both Pittsburgh and Wilkinsburg residents, filed an objection to the group’s petition, saying it was based on outdated policies. 

Common Pleas Judge Joseph James ruled in November that the 1903 law the community group based its petition on, which required only 635 signatures to put the matter back on City Council’s desk, had been repealed decades ago.

The Wilkinsburg Community Development Corporation, which has been the driving force behind both annexation efforts, appealed Judge James’s ruling to the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court. Attorney Cliff Levine, who represented the group, argued that the law was still valid because the repealed sections weren’t released according to proper procedure. 

Advertise with us

In a 17-page opinion affirming Judge James’s ruling, the Commonwealth Court wrote Thursday that the 1903 law was “invalid.” Unless new legislation is enacted offering a different method, the state court ruled, the only way to move forward with an annexation is through a referendum vote. 

Under current law, only Wilkinsburg residents would have to vote to approve the annexation, not Pittsburgh residents. Pittsburgh City Council would still have to officially approve the merger.

Previous efforts to make Wilkinsburg the 91st neighborhood in Pittsburgh were hotly contested.

The local community group first filed a petition on annexation in December 2021. A judge confirmed the petition at the time and then ordered Pittsburgh City Council to vote on the measure within three months.

Lawmakers swiftly voted against it, but some said it was because of the lack of time to investigate the lasting effects of a merger, not because they disagreed with it on the merits. Council members said that they would revisit the topic in the future. 

Advertise with us

The first round of merger discussions sparked tensions and split opinions on both sides of the municipal line. 

Members of the Wilkinsburg Borough Council, who are against a merger, severed ties with WCDC after the first petition was filed. 

And while some residents praised the idea, which could help Wilkinsburg handle blighted areas, others were worried about the possibility of gentrification. 

Wilkinsburg students in grades 7-12 already attend city schools, but the possible strain a full merger could put on the Pittsburgh Public School District had residents worried, too. 

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com