Joining the calls for better living conditions and more humane treatment of inmates of the Allegheny County Jail is the Black Political Empowerment Project.

In an open letter addressed to county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, Warden Orlando Harper and the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board, Tim Stevens, chairman and CEO of B-PEP, outlines urgent recommendations regarding the county jail facilities and staff.

On Sept. 23, 57-year-old Anthony Talotta, of Monroeville died while incarcerated at the Allegheny County Jail. According to the Allegheny County Medical Examiner, he was transported to UPMC Mercy Hospital after he was found unresponsive in the jail.

It was the sixth fatality in the jail this year and the 17th death since the beginning of the pandemic in April 2020.

Advertise with us

Included in B-PEP’s letter are two reports on the conditions in the jail that were released over the summer.

On July 31, the Pittsburgh Institute for Nonprofit Journalism published a report that found the jail’s residential kitchen had received 162 health code violations from the Allegheny County Health Department since 2014. The report also said mice were eating into the bags of food in the kitchen while cockroaches were seen crawling on kitchen walls. Black slime bubbled up from a kitchen drain where food was being prepared.

On Sept. 1, the University of Pittsburgh School of Social Work published a report that compiled survey responses from 1,418 of the 1,600 individuals who were incarcerated at the time of data collection. Respondents said there were meals with roaches and bugs, mildew in showers, withholding of medications and cold and sleepless nights. The Pitt survey respondents also claimed unqualified jail personnel — not medical staff — decided whether jail residents should see a doctor.

During a news conference Monday evening, Mr. Stevens questioned why Mr. Talotta was even put in jail.

“Why did the doctor initially decide that jail was the proper place for a man with severe intellectual disabilities, anxiety and depression versus possibly arranging for him to be transferred to Western Psychiatric Hospital?” Mr. Stevens read from his open letter. “People suffering from mental health issues and drug dependencies don't belong in jail. They deserve treatment.”

Advertise with us

The letter also mentions 53 medical staff vacancies at the Allegheny County Jail as reported by Warden Harper in a report to the Jail Oversight Board.

“We're asking you to confirm or deny did medical staff vacancies contribute to Mr. Talotta his death?” Mr. Stevens read.

On Monday, B-PEP reiterated a request made at the previous Jail Oversight Board meeting on Sept. 1. The organization asked that a committee made up of activists and community leaders be made to publicly explore and resolve long-standing problems identified in the report from Pitt.

This committee would include members of the Jail Oversight Board, the warden, the Pitt researchers who released the study, a member of B-PEP and one member each from the Alliance for Police Accountability, the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network, the Abolitionist Law Center, the Quaker Working Group Against Racism and the Pittsburgh Peace Is Possible Coalition.

While Mr. Fitzgerald announced in August a contract with the National Commission on Correctional Health Care to conduct a historical review of the fatalities that occurred within the jail, Mr. Stevens pointed out that a similar study failed three years ago.

Advertise with us

“In 2019, the county hired the NCCHC to do a similar study, after another series of deaths in the jail,” Mr. Stevens said. “The NCCHC study recommended that the jail hire more medical staff and mental health experts. According to our sources, that never happened. ... Why should we have any confidence that another NCCHC study will solve the problem this time?

“Transparency matters. By involving the public including the jail reformers and families who value the lives of their loved ones, real change will occur.”

Urgent recommendations listed in B-PEP’s letter include hiring a professional exterminator, turning up the facility’s temperature, providing blankets to prisoners, fixing the system of how medical care is provided, removing people who don't belong in jail, protecting the rights of female, gay and transgender people in jail and reviewing current leadership.

Mr. Stevens noted that B-PEP has not called for Warden Harper’s dismissal, “but ... if these things are not managed expeditiously and effectively, then there needs to be serious examination of the possibility of his termination.”

“To oversee a facility that subjects its residents to inhumane conditions is terrible but to fail to act once you have been confronted with the facts is worse,” Mr. Stevens said.

Advertise with us

Joining Mr. Stevens were members of various activist groups Monday evening.

Executive assistant of the Coalition Against Violence Shayla Holmes agreed with the points made in B-PEP’s letter.

“These conditions affect human beings,” Ms. Holmes said. “Just because they may be labeled as criminals doesn't take from the humanity that they should be shown. There are no excuses as to why these things have not been made a priority and we need to make sure that we step up and stay on top of these things until the changes are made because these inmates are suffering.”

Echoing this sentiment, Micheal Day, a pastor at Legacy International Worship Center, said it must be understood that every person in the jail matters.

“We must understand that every person in the jail still has family,” Mr. Day said. “No matter their economic status, not even their quote-unquote alleged crime. They are humans first. ... We must take action. All incarcerated lives matter.”

Advertise with us

Before the next Jail Oversight Board meeting on Oct. 6, a movement will take place at 3 p.m. in front of the City-County Building on Grant Street. Alan Guenther, a representative for both the Quaker Working Group Against Racism and the Pittsburgh Peace Is Possible Coalition, said members of local activist groups and the public will rally before going in a procession to deliver donated products to the board.

“Bring whatever you can bring,” Mr. Guenther said. “Bring towels, bring washcloths, bring the things that the inmates are lacking. They need your help. We are going to try to help them. These are the problems, we're going to try to deliver the solutions.

“We're going to offer these products to the warden and to the Jail Oversight Board and we hope they'll accept them and help these people in jail get what they need.”