If there was any question whether states wanted to push Juul, the company blamed for the teenage vaping epidemic, into a global settlement as they have with Big Tobacco and are currently doing with opioid-related companies, the announcement of an investigation agreement by 39 states put that to rest.
The agreement — trumpeted as a “bipartisan multistate investigation” by the attorneys general — is likely to “ramp up the pressure,” as Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro put it in his press release Tuesday announcing the state’s participation, and hasten the move from court to settlement with Juul, experts said.
“Thirty-nine states are taking part. That fact alone just ups the stakes exponentially for Juul and increases the incentive for them to reach a universal settlement,” said Doug Blanke, executive director of the Public Health Law Center, an anti-tobacco advocacy group based in St. Paul, Minn.
Paul Nolette, an associate professor of political science at Marquette University and an expert on the politics of state attorneys general, noted, “It was already bad enough when big states like California, New York and Pennsylvania had gone after them.
“Now [Juul] is in some real trouble now with 39 states coming after them together,” he said. “It creates even more pressure to settle.”
One aspect that could be significant, said Tina Batra Hershey, assistant professor of health policy and management at the University of Pittsburgh’s Graduate School of Public Health, is that all the first eight states but one (Arizona) have Democratic attorneys general. Getting 39 states involved shows it’s clearly now a bipartisan issue.
Read More
“I think at this point we’re at that stage in this process that there is enough feeling that this [vaping] goes across party lines and is a national problem,” Ms. Hershey said.
While other companies sell vaping products, Juul controls about 75% of the emerging U.S. market, having sold about $3.4 billion worth last year.
“It’s understandable the focus of state lawsuits is Juul,” said Dennis Henigan, vice president for legal and regulatory affairs for the Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids. “Because Juul almost single-handedly created this epidemic of youth addiction that’s caused such enormous social harm.”
Since Juul is now one-third owned by Altria, maker of Marlboro cigarettes, it could be expected to fight like a Big Tobacco company “tooth and nail” in the lawsuits filed by the eight states, including Pennsylvania two weeks ago, Mr. Blanke said.
But the sheer number of state attorneys general now using “pre-litigation discovery powers that counties” and private attorneys don’t have could prove daunting, he pointed out.
That has already started to happen in the initial eight state lawsuits.
Although the suits all share a common theme of Juul improperly targeting teenagers with deceptive advertising and misleading sciences, each so far has had new wrinkles.
Massachusetts, for example, dug into Juul’s online advertising and found the company had bought ads on kid-friendly websites for both the Nick Jr. and Cartoon Network channels — revelations that brought even further condemnation.
In its standard response since it was first sued by North Carolina in May, Juul said in response to Massachusetts’ lawsuit that it wanted to work with attorneys general and others “… to combat underage use and transition adult smokers from combustible cigarettes.”
An official from the Massachusetts attorney general’s office quipped if the goal was to get a 40-year-old mother of two to stop smoking cigarettes, rather than advertise on Nick Jr. and Cartoon Network, the company would be better off advertising on The New York Times website.
Pennsylvania’s lawsuit, filed Feb. 10 in the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia County, drilled into two aspects of Juul’s science and advertising that had not been as thoroughly explored before.
The first was taking a closer look at how Juul depicted its nicotine “absorption rate” — a measure of how fast the nicotine that users inhaled from vaping got into a person’s body. The state’s lawsuit documents how Juul not only allegedly was intentionally misleading with its packaging information but also obscured data in its patent application.
In another section of the lawsuit, Pennsylvania explained how Juul, in its early promotional efforts in 2015, targeted towns in Eastern and Central Pennsylvania by offering people free samples at Sheetz, Wawa and Rutter’s convenience stores.
Using young attractive models, the lawsuit points out, the company’s representatives set up tables with samples of Juul products, offering free puffs so people could see how it works, how it tastes and the effect it had, and then gave them for free the rest of the pod that held the nicotine liquid to take home.
“It’s a highly engaging method of marketing,” said Joe Swartz, deputy attorney general with the Tobacco Enforcement section of the office, who is the lead attorney for Pennsylvania’s case. “It puts the products and paid spokespeople in confined spaces near candy and soda, places kids go.”
Kar-Hai Chu, a University of Pittsburgh researcher who has studied social media’s role in the popularity of vaping among teenagers, said the lawsuit agrees with research he and others have found.
“We know that Juul has targeted kids on social media, and study after study shows they had an impact” on kids vaping, he said. “It wasn’t about trying to find a 55-year-old 20-year smoker and getting them to quit.”
The issues Mr. Shapiro’s lawsuit focused on “are targets we as researchers have focused on.”
Neil English, instructional principal at Riverview School District’s junior/senior high school in Oakmont, who has overseen his school’s anti-vaping efforts, was glad to see the state file its lawsuit, and not just because it might bring Juul to change its ways.
“It helps, because any sort of negative pressure against the vaping industry is good,” he said. “Just having the medical issues [from vaping lung injury cases in the past year] in the press in recent months has helped kids understand that it’s not safe.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.