In McCandless, a dog or cat that “scratches, digs or defecates” anywhere other than its own yard can be declared a “nuisance.” Their owners could be hit with steadily escalating fines, starting at $50 for the first offense - up to a maximum of $500 for the sixth time the animal is caught.

The updated “nuisance” designation there also applies to an animal that “habitually barks, howls, screeches, yelps or bays, thereby disturbing the quiet of any person or the community.”

And public pet urination is forbidden in Robinson, which requires that pets may only urinate or defecate on the owner’s property.

Though such laws are difficult if not impossible to enforce the legislation often is inspired by complaints from taxpayers who do not appreciate the sounds and smells produced by pets in their neighborhoods.

Advertise with us

That’s what happened in McCandless. Last August officials stiffened the township’s pet penalties after multiple residents complained about a family that owns more than 10 dogs that regularly bark late at night for extended periods of time.

The bans on defecation and barking — punishable with a $25 fine — had been on the books for years, noted township manager Robert Grimm. The August vote merely increased the fines.

But now some McCandless dog owners have complained that the stricter ordinance prohibits taking leashed dogs on walks, and does not give a pass to dog owners who carry bags to pick up the poop deposited by their pups.

But Mr. Grimm noted that “common sense and discretion are the watch words here....if the owner picks (waste) up that’s not a violation.”

Stricter laws expand

Advertise with us

“Draconian” dog and cat laws are popping up all over the country, according to spokespersons for the American Kennel Club and the National Animal Interest Alliance. Both national organizations track legislation.

Both organizations said they advocate for “responsible” dog and animal ownership and support “reasonable” laws.

Pet owners are “offensive and selfish” if they fail to pick up feces and/or allow dogs to bark incessantly, noted Patti L. Strand, president of alliance, which she founded in 1991. “Pet owners need to be good citizens.”

The alliance (naiaonline.org) works with municipalities to come up with reasonable laws that cover issues including pets running at large, defecating, urinating and barking.  “We’ve had some effect” in some places over the years, Ms. Strand said.

“Pick up laws” and prohibitions on excessive barking “are reasonable, and any responsible dog owner” would comply,” said Patty Van Sicklen, southeastern regional manager for the Kennel Club.

Advertise with us

But anti-defecation and urination laws can “criminalize” taking dogs on walks, she added. While conceding that uncollected feces can pose a health hazard, she speculated, “what about the squirrels, rabbits, deer and coyote?”

“A good law requires you to carry bags and clean up after your dog,” Ms. Van Sicklen said.

“The AKC recognizes the special obligation of dog owners, not only to their pets but also to their neighbors,” says the akcgr.org web site that list the organization’s position on many issues. “AKC supports ‘curbing’ and clean-up ordinances, leash laws, nuisance laws, and other reasonable regulations designed to ensure dogs and their owners remain respected members of their community.”

While neighbors not surprisingly are annoyed with and disturbed by continuous bouts of barking, animal rights advocates vilify “debarking” surgery, she noted.

“Debarking is a viable veterinary procedure ... should only be performed by a qualified, licensed veterinarian after other behavioral modification efforts to correct excessive barking have failed. ... the decision to debark a dog is best left to individual owners and veterinarians,” says the AKC website.

Advertise with us

PooPrints 

More than 4,000 apartment complexes and condominium communities in the U.S., Canada and the United Kingdom are tackling the pet problem in another way. They’ve hired  PooPrints, which advertises itself as “The DNA Solution for Dog Waste” on its website, pooprints.com.

Apartment and condo managers hire the company and swab the mouths of resident dogs. The DNA samples are sent to the parent company, BioPet Laboratories in Knoxville, Tenn. When local staff  at the communities finds pet poop that has not been picked up by owner, they send samples to the lab and offending dogs and their owner are dealt fines that can be as high as several hundred dollars.

“People don’t like to step in dog waste,’’ said Nick Boosalis, PooPrints representative for Western Pennsylvania.

The cost — generally paid by the apartment owner or condo association — is $40 per dog. There are about two dozen PooPrint customers in Western Pennsylvania, including Timber Ridge apartments in New Stanton.

Advertise with us

In the 10 years PooPrints has been in business, the firm says it has registered the DNA of more than 300,000 dogs.

Many municipalities post local ordinances regarding dogs, cats and other animals on their websites.

The Robinson website, for example, says dogs and cats are not permitted to urinate or defecate on property that is not owned by their owner, and adds that owners should immediately pick up the feces. Animals are not allowed to bark, cry or howl for more than 10 minutes.

In Mt. Lebanon, dogs are not allowed to bark, yelp or howl for 15 minutes or longer. However, an exception is indicated  if the dog is barking “in response to a person who is trespassing upon private property.”

Many municipalities have ordinances requiring dog walkers to pick up dog feces, but Mt. Lebanon does not, said Laura Pace Lilley, public information officer. There is a local law that prohibits “scattering rubbish,” and that could be applied  to dog walkers who don’t pick up, she said.

Advertise with us

“One of the most common dog complaints is about barking,” she said.  “Usually a warning and education rectifies the situation.”

Linda Wilson Fuoco: lfuoco@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1953 or at PG Pets on Facebook.  See list of Halloweeen pet events at post-gazette.com