New Castle Vigil

The road over Neshannock Creek into downtown New Castle leads to exactly what you’d expect from a city still smarting from the rust belt’s decline: boarded-up businesses, pothole-ridden streets, the occasional fast-food restaurant.

What you might not expect is the Californians.

At the counter of Two Rivers Artisan Coffee Works, Hector Marquez, 49, sports electric blue hair and greets customers by name in a laid-back surfer drawl, working alongside his wife Lisa, 46, and their three children, Noah, 16, Elousia, 10, and Revolution, 5. Six years ago, the family moved to New Castle from Sacramento to open the business.Mr. Marquez was attracted by New Castle’s low rents.

Outside the vibrant coffeehouse, many parts of downtown still feel like a ghost town — a far cry from the days older residents recall, when people crowded sidewalks and stores.

Advertise with us

Nonetheless, the coffee shop has had enough success to prompt the Marquez family to open other businesses, including a roasting house, restaurant and cigar company. Even with many storefronts and offices still vacant, in recent years the Marquez businesses have gained new neighbors, like a museum at the site of the first Warner movie theater and a headquarters for the North American Dental Group.The Marquezes plan on sticking around.

“It’s the land of opportunity,” Mr. Marquez said. “Opening and developing a business in a space like this that's next to the river is a fraction of the cost of what it would be in California.”

The low cost of business presents a possible way forward for a city whose population is aging and declining. A small but ambitious crop of business owners, local politicians and community organizers have stepped forward to offer fresh ideas and renewed hope.

One-time powerhouse

Known as the “fireworks capital of America” and the “hot dog capital of the world,” New Castle was once a global manufacturing powerhouse. Its biggest industry was tin, and its Shenango pottery once supplied china to the White House.

Advertise with us

Historic Victorian mansions on the city’s North Hill paint a picture of the spectacular wealth formerly in the city: The homes once lodged the rich men who owned New Castle’s lucrative mills along its roads and rivers during the early 1900s. But industry gradually left the city late last century, and due to New Castle’s dwindling population, rising poverty and lack of city funds for housing demolition, many of the once-stately homes are falling into disrepair.

“We are the epitome of the rust belt,” said 84-year-old Anna Mary Mooney, a longtime resident and volunteer at the historical society.

The city’s most recent population estimate is 21,797, down from its peak at nearly 49,000 in 1950. Many of those remaining are older. In the most recent census data, 19.2% of New Castle’s population was age 65 and above — a high figure even in the aging state of Pennsylvania. The city’s current mayor and city council president are both octogenarians, and both have been in office for more than a decade.

Considering the demographics, New Castle’s primary election in May was an unusual phenomenon, says Debbi Cameron, 65, a lifelong resident who manages The Ladies of the Dukes, an Italian restaurant that has served New Castle since the 1960s.

Six candidates ran for mayor, six for county commissioner, eight for city council and 14 for area school director. Many are younger than is typical for the city, according to Ms. Cameron. Her son Bryan, 30, ran and prevailed in the council primary race.

Advertise with us

“I don't remember any younger people in their 30s to 40s ever running for office like they did [this year],” she said. “They can make a change, they want to see something different come along, they want jobs, and they want to keep people here.”

Morgan Boyd, a 21-year-old public policy graduate student running for county commissioner of Lawrence County, for which New Castle is the county seat, is one of the new crop.

“The world is changing faster than anyone could possibly have imagined even 50 years ago,” said Mr. Boyd, who attends Carnegie Mellon University and sits on nearby New Wilmington’s borough council. “The best way to respond to that is to put people into government that have a respect for that.”

The changes in the candidate pool come after a long period of volatility for New Castle’s government. In 2007, the city entered the state’s Act 47 recovery program. The act is designed to help municipalities in financial distress, offering the ability to tax people commuting into the city on a temporary basis, while also subjecting the city’s budget to state oversight.

After 12 years under Act 47, New Castle has made some progress. By reducing the number of city employees while offering modest raises, the city was able to stabilize its finances. It has adopted a three-year plan to exit Act 47 in 2022. An April report from the state Department of Community and Economic Development concluded: “This thee-year Exit Plan provides a strategy to give New Castle a better chance of exiting Act 47 oversight by the end of 2022. While one of the City’s biggest challenges is its demographic weaknesses that is in part beyond the City’s control, the City can still make progress toward financial recovery by gaining the flexibility to set its resident earned income tax rate, controlling cost growth, and making its neighborhoods cleaner and more attractive.”

Advertise with us

“We've stabilized our finances because we stick to what's in the budget, don’t screw around, and don’t have the budget doing something it can't do,” Mayor Anthony Mastrangelo said.

Mr. Mastrangelo, 83, expressed concern that many of those running lack the experience to navigate the exit plan. He will leave office after finishing last out of the four Democratic candidates for mayor in May’s primary.

City Council President William Panella, a lifelong resident who has served on council for 12 years, agreed that with “no major industries whatsoever,” the city faces big challenges. He, along with two other councilmen, decided not to seek re-election this year.

“Unless we get some industry of some type, I can't see [New Castle] ever growing again,” he said.

But mayoral candidate Chris Frye, 31, believes attracting young people can help the city exit Act 47 and bring business to New Castle.

Advertise with us

“Millennials are able to take more risks.” Mr. Frye said. “We're at a time where communities are growing, urbanizing, and mixing cultures. I think that's the biggest thing is changing our culture to attract not just younger, but different folks.”

Relying on young leaders

In light of the city’s long-standing challenges, many residents say their hopes for recovery hinge not upon local politicians and but on young leaders working to improve the city outside the public sector, through business and nonprofit endeavors.

Among them is Angie Urban, the director of a downtown revitalization nonprofit called New Visions for Lawrence County. Ms. Urban, 37, is New Visions’ only paid staffer, but in the past five years has led volunteers and partnering organizations to enhance landscaping and public art downtown, create an ice rink and holiday programming, and host a summer concert series. Most recently, the group has worked with the city, consultants and other organizations to create an investment prospectus and a multi-year plan to flip vacant storefronts.

“We have more and more people that need help and less and less resources to help them, and so we have to look at our community from a different approach,” Ms. Urban said. “We basically are looking at trying to get community partners to all agree on one, maybe two, maybe three, projects that we pour all of our resources into.”

Advertise with us

One such partner is Lawrence County Blueprint Communities, a collaboration between local groups to rehabilitate the city’s Lower East Side. The effort is being spearheaded by DON Services, a nonprofit providing assistance to disabled people.

Since it first came to the Lower East Side — a neighborhood with a high concentration of poverty — Blueprint has renovated three houses and built six new ones. Projects to repair sidewalks, plant a community garden and develop a riverside trail also are underway, and the group hopes to build nine more new homes next year, according to DON Executive Vice President Court Hower.

“When you start increasing home ownership, what happens is there's not as much transiency — people moving in, people moving out,” Mr. Hower said. “It naturally starts reducing or eliminating a lot of the issues.”

Such efforts spell promise on the horizon to Ginny Jacob, a 29-year-old lifelong New Castle resident who works at Visit Lawrence County.

“There is so much great here that people just really need to get on board with,” she said. “I know we can propel it and make it way better than what it is.”

Advertise with us

Local restaurateur Abdou Saada shares Ms. Jacob’s view. Mr. Saada, 34, has operated Elham’s Restaurant with his family since they emigrated to New Castle from Syria two decades ago. He says that, despite economic challenges, he’s found business “amazing.” He has recently opened a pita shop downtown and has another under construction in nearby Hermitage, Pa.

Earlier this month, Mr. Saada’s 8-year-old nephew, Mark Mason, was stabbed to death — allegedly by his mother’s boyfriend — in a tragedy that rocked the community. But the personal loss has not stifled Mr. Saada’s optimism about New Castle. No matter what comes the city’s way, like the Marquez family, he says he never intends to leave.

“I've invested all my money in this town, and I'm going to continue to do so, because I want to be one of those people who make a difference,” he said.