Derelict buildings are coming down in New Castle, Johnstown, Kittanning and other towns in 19 counties under a 3-year-old state act meant to finance demolitions, but Allegheny County officials so far have not used the law that pays for the wrecking ball using new fees on deeds and mortgages.
"Some boroughs and townships are putting [sites of tumbledown houses] back into greenspace, or parking space," or trying to redevelop them, said Thomas C. Chernisky, president of the commissioners of Cambria County, where the law has enabled a half dozen demolitions, and counting. "When you have a blighted property that's no longer there, and you see greenspace, or parking, or somebody turning it into a side yard, that's a good news story.”
Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Fayette and Westmoreland counties have also tacked fees of as much as $15 on to deed and mortgage filings under the law. It requires that the money raised go toward demolition of blighted properties.
And Allegheny County?
“We're going to take a look at it, and I've got to go to [county] council to see where we are,” said Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald on Thursday. He’s concerned that it would push the total fees on each deed filed in the county up around $200.
A longtime opponent of property tax hikes, he said the fee “would be a little different [from a tax], but it's still on property. One of the things I've always wanted to see is more investment in property,” and a new fee might deter purchases.
Read More
Some local officials counter that a $15 fee on deeds and mortgages would be worthwhile if it cleared some of the county’s thousands of abandoned houses.
“There’s a clear need for demolition," said David Pasternak, president of both White Oak Borough Council and the Steel Rivers Council of Governments board, who called the prospective $15 fee “small.” His home borough has just a few candidates for demolition, but in some neighboring municipalities 1 in 5 houses is empty. “For the communities that border us, it would help immensely.”
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, in a series on child poverty called Growing up through the Cracks, recently highlighted the hazards to children posed by vacant properties in North Braddock. Mr. Fitzgerald said then that "resources aren’t really available" to increase county support for demolitions.
State Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill, wrote Act 152 of 2016 because the former mining towns he represents were also straining to find money to demolish houses. He thought of using a fee on deeds and mortgages because reducing blight may spur the real estate market. "Any time you're improving a community, that's good for the owners of property, that's good for the renters of property, that's good for the sellers of property — that's good for everybody," he said in late July.
When real estate interests called to oppose it, he recounted, he’d say, "Show me another way to help these communities tear down these dilapidated buildings.” His bill passed the House, 164-25, and the Senate, 47-0, before winning Gov. Tom Wolf's signature.
To impose the fee and fill the demolition fund, counties need to pass legislation. “I think Lawrence County might’ve been the first” to do so, said Jim Gagliano, executive director of that county’s redevelopment authority. “We didn’t get any negative feedback.”
There, the fee has raised $158,000, he said, and has backed demolition of “maybe 25 homes.”
In Westmoreland County, the fee raises around $300,000 a year. It could raise several times that for Allegheny County, enabling scores of demolitions annually. Demolition costs vary, coming in under $10,000 per house when clusters of derelicts are bid out together, and ranging up beyond $40,000 for a single large house containing asbestos.
Some Allegheny County Council members are hesitant to sign on to any property-related fee.
"It's hard for me to believe that O'Hara, Fox Chapel, Findlay, Moon, Mount Lebanon, are ready to kick in $15 for something that wouldn't really apply to their neighborhoods,” fretted Councilman Bob Macey, D-West Mifflin. "If we go do this, the electorate would say, ‘There they go again, backdooring us on money and taxes.’”
His district includes communities ranging from White Oak, where just 6% of houses are vacant, per Census estimates, to Duquesne, where it’s 22%. He said he doesn’t know how to address the vacant housing problem, and it’s “not something that will be solved with the strike of a pen or because somebody had a great idea."
“When you’re talking about blighted property, there is no one, single sword that can slay it,” agreed county Councilman Pat Catena, D-Carnegie, a former borough council president. “I’m just not convinced that adding another fee or tax to anything solves any problems.”
The Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh generally opposes “anything that adds costs to a buyer or seller,” said John Petrack, its executive vice president. But he took a nuanced view of using a deed fee to pay for demolition. “Obviously anything that helps eradicate blight within the city or county is helpful," he said, adding that a $15 fee is "relatively nominal.”
In Clairton, roughly 1,000 of the 4,000 houses are vacant, and the city has no money to address it, said Mayor Richard Lattanzi.
"There's four or five buildings that we have yellow tape around," he said, "to keep people from walking too close to the buildings,” for fear falling bricks might hit them.
"I don't want young people going into these old homes in any community, and have their parents worry about whether they're exposed to asbestos or lead-based paint because we didn't have enough money to tear these buildings down,” said state Sen. James Brewster, D-McKeesport, whose district includes Clairton and North Braddock. Raze the derelict houses, he said, and “we won't lose people who are leaving their homes because they can't control what's going on right next door to them.”
Rasheda Campbell and her sons, ages 18 and 16, hope to leave North Braddock’s Stokes Avenue, where the house next to theirs collapsed in early spring. The borough sought county aid to pay for demolition of the collapsed house, but the county denied it, so the wreckage remains.
“My son wanted a basketball hoop back here, but I don’t think we can really do anything back here,” Ms. Campbell said, as she stood in her back yard, next to rubble barely restrained by privacy fencing. “I never know when it’s going to slide again.”
Mr. Brewster wants the county to adopt the deed fee to fund demolition. He has also introduced legislation that would put new fees on sheriff’s sales and tax sales for the same purpose, and in May he wrote to Mr. Fitzgerald suggesting that air pollution fines be put toward razing environmentally compromised houses.
Mr. Fitzgerald’s preferred solution is Mr. Wolf’s Restore PA plan, which would institute a tax on shale gas drilling to raise billions for infrastructure. Democrats have introduced Restore PA bills in the House and Senate, where Mr. Brewster is among the sponsors. Republicans, though, control both chambers.
Restore PA is the most comprehensive solution, said Rick Verillo, deputy secretary of community affairs with the state Department of Community and Economic Development. In the meantime, he hopes that more counties join the 19 that are using the deed and mortgage fee to address blight.
"Local government and county government are slow to change, and part of the challenge is — even though it's not, really — [the fee] is perceived as a tax in some areas," he said. "To me, it's a great idea and a way to raise funds that is not a tax. ... It's making a difference in places that have the fee."
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.