How do you persuade someone to train 200 hours to be prepared to step out of bed in the middle of the night and rush to the station for a siren ride to a burning building that may take hours to extinguish, with the added stress of potential casualties?
For no pay.
“And then drag into work on two hours of sleep,” said Bill Jeffcoat, chief of Penn Hills Volunteer Fire Company #7. “I still haven’t figured it out.”
The only thing more strained than staffing in the world of volunteer firefighting is funding, so much so that every year, politicians, policy advocates and firefighters describe a deepening crisis.

In Pennsylvania, 38,000 volunteers fight fires today compared to 60,000 in the early 2000s and 300,000 in the 1970s, according to a recent study by the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public and International Affairs.
The decline coincides with the waning importance of the fire hall as a town’s center of activity and the loss of industry that once made volunteers available in shifts, said state Fire Commissioner Bruce Trego, who calls volunteer first responders “a special breed.”
Another reason, say some, is a dwindling spirit for public service in general.
The Congress of Neighboring Communities commissioned the study, which offers solutions, such as paying some first responders to staff volunteer stations; paying drivers; and creating a county pool of paid professionals to farm out to municipalities with low manpower.
It could not be determined how many females volunteer as firefighters in the county or state. Steve Imbarlina, the county’s assistant chief of emergency services, said the county does not track demographic information. Nationally, about 4% are women, according to the U.S. Department of Labor.
Some fire stations use free room and board at the station to recruit, including several in Monroeville and one in Ross. In 2016, Penn Hills #7 invested in a neighboring building. Several downstairs tenants’ rents pay the mortgage and support the station. Upstairs is a free residence, with several bunks for transient volunteers.
Penn Hills fire department's live-in program is "like a second family" to volunteers
Even the lure of free college tuition has not rallied enough people to the cause. In the 10 years that Community College of Allegheny County has offered free tuition to any student who will commit to five years of service to a volunteer company in the county, the highest number of recruits was 53 in 2013. CCAC has capacity to serve 200 a year, said Elizabeth Johnston, a CCAC spokeswoman.
In the past five years, 285 volunteer firefighters received a CCAC scholarship, she said. They have served in 74 volunteer departments in the county, she said, adding, “They save the county $60 million a year, so they are a great investment.”
So far in 2019, the program has recruited five new students.
“It is insane that more people do not take advantage of that,” said Mr. Jeffcoat, a 20-year veteran of fire service, having started as a junior firefighter at age 16. “There are no junior firefighters at our station now.
“I’ve gone to high schools with pamphlets and information,” he said, referring to the Fire VEST scholarship, short for Volunteer Education, Service and Training. “But not enough people sign up.”
Matt Brown, Allegheny County chief of emergency services, echoed Mr. Jeffcoat’s surprise: “People join the Army and National Guard for the college. For fire departments, it can be recruitment or a retention tool.”
Mr. Trego said he has heard a variety of estimates of the value of volunteer first responders in the state, one being $6 billion. “I don’t know if that’s accurate, but I can tell you there is no cookie cutter solution for the entire commonwealth.”
Mr. Brown said departments are testing ways to be more efficient, including joining forces, but county-based solutions, such as a pool of firefighters, would require funding for a county fire department and a pool coordinator.
Allegheny County has 130 municipalities and 170 fire departments. All but a few are volunteer. Almost all are 501c3 nonprofit entities, separate from the municipality, although some municipalities provide support. Penn Hills gives $55,000 a year for each of six companies, Mr. Jeffcoat said.
Mr. Trego’s state office gets grant requests from about 2,200 volunteer companies, his estimate of how many there are. The state raised the grant pool several years ago from $25 million to $30 million, he said, which was “maybe just enough to maintain the heating bills.”
Volunteer services depend on state grants, low-interest state loans, public donations and fund-raisers — hoagie sales, fish fries, bingo, bake sales and raffles for anything from a freezer full of meat to a Disney vacation. One fundraiser at Penn Hills #7, a gun raffle that sells 1,000 tickets, raises $35,000, which is 5% to 10% of the operating budget, Mr. Jeffcoat said.

“I have to constantly bug people for money,” he said, adding that donations from a letter campaign to residents decline every year. “We have a fill-the-boot day once a year, and I stand in traffic asking for spare change. I hate it and I hate asking my members to do that. It shouldn’t have to come to that.”
Imbalance of equipment
Another finding in the Pitt report is a disproportion of equipment in comparisons between Allegheny County and New York City. With a population eight times smaller, Allegheny County has double the number of fire engines and only six fewer aerial trucks. Aerial trucks cost about $1 million each.
Mr. Trego said it might be time for a comprehensive community study of what equipment and how many people are needed, the number of companies and areas they are protecting: “I’m not saying we have too many, but a strategic outlook might be called for.”
Mr. Jeffcoat, who works as a 911 dispatcher for the county, said the aspect of firefighting that would daunt most people is what draws a person to volunteer for the task.
“It’s hard for an outsider to understand this,” he said, “but all we want to do is run fire calls. If I could just do that, life would be perfect.”
“We thrive on the fire calls,” said Mr. Imbarlina, who spent 27 years as an active member of the Unity fire department in Plum.
The volunteer first-responder is both an altruist and an adrenaline junkie. The commitment can also run in families.
“Of 330 employees in our emergency services,” Mr. Brown said, “everyone has either been a volunteer or has a family member who has been.”
Alex Popko has fought fires with companies in the center of the state, as well as in Wilkins and Penn Hills. He lives in station #7’s dormitory and works for pay as a 911 county dispatcher.
Firefighting, he said, “seemed like a cool thing to do. Ever since I was a kid, my family has been involved in community service. When I started, my love for it grew right away. There’s an adrenaline rush.”
“A lot of people who do ambulance also do this,” said Larry Zamora, first captain at Penn Hills #7. “There are 230 to 240 people at the county 911 call center and at least half are also first responders. It can be fun, but it takes a special person to stick with it.”
Mr. Jeffcoat said his 41-man roster has a fairly wide age range, but a growing number have trouble running up five flights of stairs for an elevator emergency
“If we don’t recruit,” he said, “our young guys will soon be our old guys.”
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.