A new report that says retail theft across the state is down just doesn’t match the view from behind the desks in the Frazer Police Department, which is actually based inside one of Allegheny County’s shopping malls.

“I have no idea why it could be decreasing because we’re doing just fine,” in terms of making cases, said Sgt. Aaron Scott, from the Frazer police station within the Galleria at Pittsburgh Mills on Wednesday as post-holiday shoppers returned unwanted gifts and sought sales.

Sgt. Scott said on average his department receives about 20 theft complaints per month, including 15 for retail theft. Often they’re for people walking out with concealed merchandise and “under-ringing” at self-checkout.

“That’s becoming more predominant. Say you buy $100 of merchandise, but only scan $70,” he said.

Advertise with us

While the courts count a 15 percent decrease in shoplifting cases statewide between 2013 and 2017, Allegheny County leads the state for the highest number of retail theft offenses, according to a December report by Pennsylvania’s Unified Judicial System.

Allegheny County, with 5,615 retail thefts in 2017, is followed by Philadelphia County with 4,051 and Montgomery County with 2,755.

Frazer, a municipality of just over 1,100 in Allegheny County, ranks second in the state for larceny and theft per capita, according to FBI data.

“People steal for a lot of reasons,” Sgt. Scott said. “Maybe they need food or diapers for their kids. But then you have people who are pushing out four TVs. Some people are addicted to drugs and are stealing things to pawn off.”

Homestead Chief Jeff DeSimone shares Sgt. Scott’s disbelief, saying retail theft is “pretty steady” in his municipality, which ranks fourth in the state for per capita larceny and theft.

Advertise with us

Like Frazer, Homestead encompasses a large shopping area: Roughly 60 percent of the Waterfront open-air mall sits within its borders.

“My opinion is I think a lot needs to be done on the justice side of it,” Chief DeSimone said. “We’re arresting people with ten, twenty retail thefts, and they’re trying to settle [their cases] at the magistrate and nobody’s really going to jail for it, so what is the deterrent?”

Shoplifting prevention and retail experts say they’ve seen an increase nationwide, not a decrease.

“[Numbers] might be down because it’s not being reported or because retailers are not reporting it because the court system is doing nothing about it,” said Barbara Staib, director of communications for the National Association for Shoplifting Prevention. Ms. Staib’s organization maintains that “shoplifting has become one of the most prevalent crimes in the U.S.” with roughly 550,000 incidents happening per day.

The National Retail Federation reports that 2018 was an all-time high for organized retail crime, costing retailers $777,877 per every billion dollars in sales.

Advertise with us

Ms. Staib said she could not speak to why retail theft is down across Pennsylvania but did say that in recent years 37 states have raised their felony thresholds, meaning that more thefts could remain at summary or misdemeanor levels.

“When the felony threshold goes up and the community is not handling misdemeanor crime as they used to, reported crime goes down, but it’s a myth,” she said. “Property crime is likely going down because we’re putting a much lower priority to it. However, it’s a slippery slope when you start decriminalizing, even in a de facto way, theft and low-level crime.”

Under Pennsylvania law, a first retail theft offense for merchandise under $150 is considered a summary crime; it becomes a misdemeanor in the second degree for a second offense under that set value. A first or second offense for stealing merchandise worth more than $150 is a misdemeanor in the first degree. It becomes a felony on the third or subsequent time, regardless of merchandise value.

The national trend toward reducing incarceration for property crimes made an appearance in the General Assembly earlier this year.

In February, Rep. Dan Miller (D-Allegheny County) introduced a bill to amend retail theft punishment, making it a felony only if the merchandise worth exceeds $1,000.

Advertise with us

The bill did not reach the floor. Mr. Miller could not be reached for comment.

Of the 243,305 retail theft offenses committed in Pennsylvania from 2013 to 2017, 52 percent resulted in convictions, the report states.

Kimberly Bathgate, spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania courts, said she doesn’t know the reason behind the decline in retail theft in Pennsylvania.

“Unfortunately the courts can’t analyze the data,” she said. “We just provide it. It comes right out of our case management system. It essentially comes down to how many times there were citations.”

Sgt. Scott said that retailers may be able to deter theft with “good quality cameras and software to run those cameras.” Chief DeSimone said that having more retailers “on the same page” about repercussions would be a positive change.

Advertise with us

“Some retailers are very aggressive in their approach,” said Chief DeSimone. “They’ll follow [the shoplifter] outside. Others are not. Then they‘ll call us. My point to them is if you’re not going to follow through, then why are you calling us? You’re putting us in harm’s ways.”

He highlighted one call his department received for an active shoplifting incident as the epitome of the enforcement problem.

“And this incident, [the shoplifters] came prepared. One person’s job was to distract and the others packed their foil-lined bags with items,” he said. “We were going balls to walls to get there. ... And at the end of the day, the store didn’t want to prosecute.”

Ashley Murray: 412-263-1750, amurray@post-gazette.com or on Twitter at @Ashley__Murray