It was said to be the “war to end all wars,” and when World War I ended at 11 a.m., on the 11th day of the 11th month of 1918, in part because of America’s intervention 19 months earlier, the world, and Pittsburgh, rejoiced.

Millions were killed during the four-year war in Europe, including 116,708 American military personnel - 10,278 of them, or nearly 10 percent of the total, were from Pennsylvania, and 1,527 of them from Allegheny County alone.
And Pittsburgh’s involvement in the war long preceded the government’s declaration of war in 1917.
“Almost from the beginning of the war [in 1914] it was a daily concern in Pittsburgh,” said Elizabeth Williams-Hermann, author of the 2013 book “Pittsburgh in World War I: Arsenal of the Allies.” “That was due in part to the large groups of English and Germans here and because Pittsburgh industry supplied the allies from the start of the war.”
But despite the many local troops who died fighting in Europe, and the local investment in the war, today memories of World War I and its importance have faded locally, and interest in marking the centennial of the end of the war is minimal, Ms. Williams-Hermann and veterans themselves say.
And that is in spite of the fact that Veterans Day was originally celebrated as Armistice Day on Nov. 11 to mark the end of World War I.
Read More
“I think that World War I is often forgotten in the shuffle of history,” she said. “World War II was bigger. And while who the good guys and the bad guys in World War I is complicated, you can’t get any more evil than Hitler in World War II.”

Though there are many World War I memorials in towns all over the Pittsburgh region, at 11 a.m. on Sunday there will be few ceremonies marking the 100th anniversary of the end of “The Great War.”
A national group called Bells of Peace has been trying for three years to organize commemorations across the country of the moment the guns fell silent in Europe, and have had success in the Philadelphia region and elsewhere.
The director in charge of organizing efforts in Pennsylvania, Barry Johnson, said that despite emails and calls to veterans groups and other organizations all over the Pittsburgh region, he has had no response.
“I’ve been doing this for three years,” Mr. Johnson said in an email response to questions from the Post-Gazette last week. “I get virtually nothing but radio silence from Western Pennsylvania.”
There are three noted bell ringing ceremonies at 11 a.m. on Sunday in the region.
Both Allegheny and Homewood cemeteries – which both are home to the final resting places of dozens of World War I veterans and some who died in action – will ring bells in their tower and chapel, respectively, 21 times at 11 a.m. on Sunday.
And most prominently, Soldiers & Sailors Memorial Hall & Museum in Oakland will hold a bell ringing at 11 a.m. Sunday, along with the opening of an expanded World War I exhibit in the museum.
But, notably, none of those three bell ringing ceremonies is being done in conjunction with any local VFW, American Legion or other veterans groups.
Even the annual Veterans Day Parade Saturday in Downtown was only to mention the centennial of the end of World War I.
“We will announce that it is the 100th anniversary at the reviewing stand at the end of the parade,” said Tony Filardi, chairman of the Veterans Day Parade since 1990.
He lamented that people “don’t even know it was originally Armistice Day. We try to tell them. But they don’t even teach that in the schools. Knowledge of Veterans Day is going downhill.”

Bill Roland, commander of the Allegheny County VFW district, had a similar concern.
He did not know of any ceremonies on Sunday marking the end of the war beyond the cemetery and Soldiers & Sailors events.
“To be honest, it’s a little frustrating because I’d like to be able to celebrate with our veterans,” he said. “But as time goes on those things [like World War I] are forgotten.”
He said some of the Veterans Day events going on during this past week in schools and local communities do note that this is the 100th anniversary of the end of the war. But they aren’t specific events marking the centennial.
And while the history may seemingly be lost to time, in local cemeteries the history seems obvious to those who work there.
“There is so much World War I history right here,” said Jennie Benford, director of programming at Homewood Cemetery, which straddles Point Breeze and Squirrel Hill.
Much of it is not obvious, though. Many of the veterans who died after the war did not note their service in the war, and some of those troops who died in action and whose families brought their remains back also did not note their service.
“But in research we’ve found many interesting stories,” she said.

That includes the gravesite of Donald C. Jefferson, who was part of an African-America artillery battalion that served in Europe and who later became a pharmacist. His elegant, but plain, gravestone notes that he was born in 1895 and died in 1994, but nothing about his unique place in the history of World War I.
Homewood is also home to the gravesite of a man who may have saved more troops than anyone during World War I. James B. Garner was a chemist and Mellon Institute researcher who invented the gas mask credited with saving the lives of perhaps hundreds of thousands during the war, when gas was widely used as a weapon. His second wife, Glenna, also a chemist, buried two graves away from him, is credited with designing the mask.
The same is true at Allegheny Cemetery in Lawrenceville.
“A lot of these monuments are humble renditions of names and dates,” said Roger Galbraith, superintendent, historian and tour guide at Allegheny. “But if the stones could talk, they’d tell us a lot of history.”
One of those stories is of William Thaw, a son to a rich Pittsburgh family, who is buried in one of those humble plots that notes nothing of his military exploits. He not only volunteered to fight, he volunteered to fight before America entered the war. He fought for France beginning in 1915, wanting to be a pilot. He was at first turned down and fought on the front lines, but later became a fighter pilot and shot down 20 German airplanes during the war.
But few people come any more to visit these old graves, Mr. Galbraith said, perhaps for the same reasons ceremonies marking the armistice at 11 a.m. Sunday are scarce.
“As each generation passes, the visitations, the relevance kind of diminishes,” he said.
Still, the cemetery will ring its bell 21 times Sunday morning, with little ceremony beyond the sounds.
Without context, will people in 2018 understand what it meant 100 years ago?
“I hope they do,” Mr. Galbraith said. “I’m afraid they won’t.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.