Before Karen Allgeier moved to Brookville 14 years ago, she enjoyed her time in the San Diego area, where she acted in a community theater group.

But her time as treasurer and director of Brookville Community Theater is dramatically different.

“The community here, the people who are involved in Brookville are just much more involved,” Ms. Allgeier said of the Jefferson County borough of about 3,800 residents. “California is 10 times busier ... so when you can get a large portion of [Brookville] people to support you, it’s amazing. The town is so vibrant when we do this.”

The support extends to Ms. Allgeier’s efforts to restore the Columbia Theater, which hosted many movies and shows in the early 20th century but has been mostly dormant since the 1960s. Ms. Allgeier has raised nearly enough money to begin working on the lobby of the building on Main Street, she said, in hopes of turning it into a performing arts center that could also have movie showings.

Advertise with us

It’s the type of project that Ms. Allgeier and other residents say they appreciate about Brookville, a county seat that many residents describe as prideful, well-kept, crime-free and home to a surprising array of activities and pastimes.

“We’re spoiled,” said Espranza Palmer, who works in insurance and has lived in Brookville for nearly 25 years. “We don’t realize what we have here, and how much we have.”

A local band performs next to the Jefferson County courthouse during the annual Brookville Laurel Festival, Wednesday, June 20, 2018, in Brookville. (James Crabtree-Hannigan/Post-Gazette)

Ms. Palmer’s daughter, Camille, had to leave Brookville to appreciate it. Camille, 23, never thought she would want to come back home when she left for Mount Aloysius College in Cresson, Cambria County. But once she got there, she missed the sense of safety she feels in her hometown, located about 70 miles northeast of Pittsburgh.

“When I moved back, I was like, ‘OK, this is a lot better,’” Camille Palmer said. “I would raise my kids here, when I eventually have them.”

Ken Burkett, executive director of the Jefferson County Historical Society, said many Brookville natives move away in young adulthood but return to raise a family, or when they’re retirement age. That partially explains the town having a relatively old population, with 21.5 percent age 65 or older.

Advertise with us

“The people of the community here are very cognizant of the historical background,” Mr. Burkett said, “and keeping the community with a historical flavor to it.”

Founded in 1830 as a lumber mill town, Brookville owes its beginnings to the many creeks and rivers that connected it to surrounding areas. As the lumber industry contracted, coal mining and other industrialization developed and maintained Brookville’s prosperity.

Those natural features don’t fuel Brookville’s economy the way they used to, but the outdoors still figures prominently in the lives of many Brookville residents. Nearby Cook Forest State Park and other sites offer plenty of hunting and fishing opportunities. Hiking is popular at the state park and Scripture Walks Heritage Park, as well as the Riverwalk and Redbank Valley Trail, which are accessible from downtown.

But Brookville is hardly secluded or inaccessible, with Interstate 80 and Route 28 running through it. That makes it vulnerable to bigger-city problems such as drug infiltration, police Chief Vince Markle said.

“I-80 is a straight shot to New York, [and] 28’s Pittsburgh,” Chief Markle said.

Advertise with us

But Brookville doesn’t have a drug epidemic, many residents said.

In fact, you’re more likely to hear people discuss news related to marijuana than heroin or fentanyl: Cresco Yeltrah, a Chicago-based medical cannabis cultivator, opened a grower-processor facility in Brookville that began full operation in February. The facility employs around 35 people and expects to have about 60 employees this fall, a company spokesman said.

In addition, Beverage-Air, Brookville Equipment Corp. and Berry Global Plastics all have factories in the area, accounting for many of the employment opportunities in Brookville.

Main Street, meanwhile, is filled with numerous law and insurance offices near the Jefferson County Courthouse. The area has six antique stores, along with Fusion Ateleir, a storefront dedicated to local artists.

Cars travel through downtown Brookville, Wednesday, June 20, 2018. (James Crabtree-Hannigan/Post-Gazette)

Bill Stein, 43, moved to Brookville from New Kensington nearly 15 years ago and co-founded CREATE Brookville, an arts-oriented company that operates out of Fusion Ateleir. Making a living in the arts in such a small town is difficult, Mr. Stein said, so he also runs a cafe, a photography studio and a framing shop, in addition to giving art lessons.

Advertise with us

He believes the town offers an opportunity to lead a quiet, rewarding life in beautiful surroundings.

“Most small towns, you walk through and all the businesses are boarded up on Main Street and buildings are dilapidated and falling apart,” Mr. Stein said. “But the community of Brookville has done a fantastic job of maintaining the historical look, and the businesses on Main Street are thriving.”

Ms. Allgeier, like Mr. Stein, found Brookville a perfect place to pursue her passions. She married into Brookville — her husband’s family has been in the town since the mid-1800s — and enjoys the small-town lifestyle.

“A great place to raise your kids, great place if you are into outdoor sports or hiking or biking,” Ms. Allgeier said. “There are so many things that are intrinsic to Brookville that you can’t find in the big city.”

Aside from restoring the Columbia, she runs a community theater that actually feels like a part of the community. Taking that into account, she’s careful to schedule performances around other local events like gun raffles and charity dinners.

“They can’t wait for our next show,” Ms. Allgeier said. “It’s all about the community. It’s all about getting people involved in things in Brookville.”