The Diocese of Erie’s past and present bishops are defending their supervision of a priest who was arrested Tuesday on charges of sexual abuse and who stayed in ministry for eight years after admitting his attraction to boys and to sending them sexually themed texts.

The statements came a day after the arrest of the Rev. David L. Poul­son of Oil City on charges of sexually abusing two boys between 2002 and 2010.

Both bishops sought to rebut Attorney General Josh Shapiro’s statement that “for years, the Diocese of Erie turned a blind eye to child abuse by Father David Poulson.”

Erie Bishop Emeritus Donald W. Trautman said in a written statement there “was no cover-up of sexual abuse.”

Advertise with us

Current Bishop Lawrence Persico said it was the diocese itself, based on new information, that provided information to authorities in January 2018 that led to Father Poulson’s arrest.

Father Poulson, 64, was indicted by the 40th statewide grand jury, which has been investigating sexual abuse in Erie’s and five other Catholic dioceses. He faces charges in Jefferson County, part of the 13-county Diocese of Erie.

The indictment cited a 2010 internal memo in which Bishop Trautman confronted Father Poulson over a third-hand report of a young man’s interactions with the priest, allegations that did not include physical contact, according to Bishop Trautman.

Bishop Trautman said the young man did not respond to his many attempts to reach him. According to the grand jury report, Bishop Trautman confronted the priest, who admitted to his arousal by a boy, to sending sexually themed texts and to spending time alone with boys in violation of diocesan rules.

Bishop Trautman, according to the grand jury, told the priest to “cease and desist” from his problematic behavior with minors.

Advertise with us

Bishop Trautman on Wednesday noted that he received no other allegations against Father Poulson through the bishop’s 2012 retirement. His statement did not address why, given what the priest did admit, Father Poulson remained in parish ministry through early 2018.

“I devoted a significant part of my tenure as bishop of the Diocese of Erie to the important issue of abuse within the church,” Bishop Trautman said, citing his dismissal of 22 priests from ministry due to sexual abuse, his establishment of an independent board to review such cases, his role in developing national policies in response to abuse and his hiring former FBI agents to review diocesan records.

The Diocese of Erie on Wednesday corrected a news release that said diocesan representatives tried in 2017 to reach the young man in the 2010 memo. The diocese said that effort took place in 2018.

Current Bishop Lawrence Persico, in a Wednesday news conference, reiterated that nobody raised any concerns to him about Father Poulson.

He said early in his tenure, he asked the Erie County District Attorney to review confidential priest-personnel files, which he said filled four file cabinets. That review revealed cases of priests already removed from ministry, he said, but was still in progress when the grand jury subpoenaed documents in 2016.

Advertise with us

A law firm retained by the diocese had been going through the files since the subpoena. But Bishop Persico said he had them prioritize searching Father Poulson’s files when a call came from a Roman Catholic chaplain at Fort Hood, Texas, saying that a soldier reported being repeatedly sexually abused by Father Poulson.

That, Bishop Persico said, is when the 2010 memo was retrieved.

New efforts to contact the young man identified in the document were still unsuccessful, but Bishop Persico said the diocese also notified local and state law enforcement and provided crucial information leading to the arrest.

The diocese confronted Father Poulson, who admitted taking minors to a rural cabin and being attracted to young men, and the diocese provided state investigators these admissions and numerous names of potential witnesses from the priest’s contacts, according to Bishop Persico.

“The Diocese of Erie has put a great deal of time and effort into making sure that every possible action is taken to ensure the safety of children and vulnerable adults,” he said.

Advertise with us

Asked at the press conference what he would have done if he had learned of the 2010 memo earlier, he said he probably would have turned it over to law enforcement.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.