Angus McEachran, the suffer-no-fools executive editor of The Pittsburgh Press when it won consecutive Pulitzer Prizes in the late 1980s, died Monday after a sudden illness in his native Memphis. He was 78.
Mr. McEachran began his newspaper career as a copy clerk at The Commercial Appeal newspaper in Tennessee in 1960 and rose to become editor. He oversaw the coverage of the two biggest stories in Memphis at the time: Martin Luther King Jr.'s assassination in 1968 and Elvis Presley's death in 1977.
He then served as editor of the Birmingham Post-Herald before joining The Pittsburgh Press in 1982. He was named executive editor of the Press in 1983, and was its editor when the paper won Pulitzer Prizes in 1986 and 1987 for investigative journalism.
He led the newpaper until a 1992 work stoppage brought its closure and sale to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette early in 1993.
“The last 10 years of the Pittsburgh Press were the best 10 years of the Pittsburgh Press,” longtime Press reporter Larry Walsh, 76, said of Mr. McEachran’s tenure.
Mr. McEachran — pronounced mick-Kar-en — had been sent by the parent company, Scripps Howard Newspapers, to shake up the biggest paper in the chain. With a Southern drawl that could rise in decibels if he encountered shoddy work but soften when he told a joke, he approached Mr. Walsh about two weeks into his tenure and asked, “How long have the inmates been running the asylum?”
“That’s why Scripps-Howard sent you here,’’ Mr. Walsh recalled telling him.
Mr. McEachran knew talent was waiting to be unleashed in Pittsburgh because Madelyn Ross had organized writers’ lunches where reporters and photographers went on their own time to bat around ways to improve the product. Unbeknownst to Ms. Ross, someone had been sending her written summaries of each session to the chain’s headquarters in Cincinnati, and Mr. McEachran had read them all.
“I think we have a lot of work to do,’’ he told Ms. Ross after arriving from the Scripps paper in Birmingham, Ala. “But I also think we have the talent.’’
She’d been at the paper full-time for 10 years by 1983, when Mr. McEachran “plucked a 32-year-old woman to be his managing editor.’’ That was a fairly bold move in a macho, blue-collar town reeling from the implosion of the steel industry, but Mr. McEachran wanted his newspaper to be worthy of a place calling itself The City of Champions.
For those willing to work, he’d give everything he had. “He brought big ambition to Pittsburgh and the paper,’’ said Mary Pat Flaherty, who along with Andrew Schneider was awarded the 1986 Pulitzer Prize in specialized reporting for their investigation of the organ transplantation system.
At the time, locals were justifiably proud of the organ transplants in the hospitals that would become UPMC, “so it was no small thing to be writing in a way that was not laudatory,’’ Ms. Flaherty said. But when Mr. McEachran was asked if he would fly two reporters all over the world to report on trafficking in human organs, he OK’d the considerable expenses.
He had an eye for talent: he hired Rob Rogers for a three-month internship to draw editorial cartoons in 1984; Mr. Rogers is now in his 34th year as an award-winning political cartoonist.
Mr. Rogers said Mr. McEachran had a cartoon in his office, drawn by someone at his previous paper, that depicted “Angus” reading a reporter's copy, tearing it into shreds and stomping on it.
“According to legend, this was not even an exaggeration,” Mr. Rogers said.
Mr. McEachran also offered a young Reed Smith attorney, Robert Bianco, a part-time job as a restaurant critic in 1984.
When Mr. Bianco confessed he was a teetotaller and hoped that wouldn’t hinder his reviews, Mr. McEachran told him, “If I think it’s a problem, I’ll fire you.’’
“That was Angus,’’ said Mr. Bianco, who would become the television critic for the Press, the Post-Gazette and ultimately a 19-year stint with USA Today. “Direct, sometimes brutally funny, sometimes just brutal. Either way, you knew where you stood with Angus and you knew what he wanted — and most of the time, you knew what he wanted was right.’’’
Not everyone was a fan of the temperament of this man who once said another guy didn’t “have enough sense to pour piss out of a boot if the instructions were on the heel.’’ Current PG reporter David Templeton was never the focus of Mr. McEachran’s wrath, but he never felt comfortable with the bullying he witnessed at the Press.
“I felt it was detrimental to good journalism and workplace morale,’’ Mr. Templeton said. “Bullying should never be tolerated or celebrated, now or three decades ago.’’
But the editor’s anger was certain if he believed someone had not given their all, or had demonstrated a lack of ethics.
“People disappeared from the newsroom and people didn’t know why,’’ Ms. Ross said. “If you betrayed the newsroom, you were gone.’’
Otis Sanford, now a professor of journalism at the University of Memphis, was still in college when he met the man he’d come to trust “beyond explanation.’’ The summer before his junior year at the University of Mississippi, Mr. Sanford walked into the newsroom of the Memphis Commercial Appeal and asked this gruff man for a summer job.
Mr. Sanford left a phone number and went home to the farm in Mississippi. Just before he was to start work at a furniture factory, Mr. McEachran called and said, “If you want a job, get your butt back to Memphis.
“That was the beginning of a relationship that lasted 45 years.’’
Mr. Sanford was working for Mr. McEachran in August 1977 when Angus yelled for him to head down to Baptist Memorial Hospital because “Elvis is there.’’ Mr. Sanford literally ran to the hospital and had the front-page story the next day of Elvis Presley’s death.
Another editor might have overthought it and not sent a black reporter to cover a singer who was an icon of the white community, but Mr. McEachran never chose anyone to cover anything based on race, Mr. Sanford said. If you were a reporter, you ought to be able to cover any story or “you shouldn’t be there.
“I trusted Angus with my career. I believed in him. I knew the kind of journalist he was. I knew his faults, his temper, but I also knew his care.’’
He talked Mr. Sanford, newly married with a combined family of three children, into leaving a job as the assistant metro editor in Memphis to come to Pittsburgh in 1987. Mr. Sanford knew nothing about the city, but he knew the newspaper was winning Pulitzers, and Mr. McEachran lured him east with one phrase: “I’m going to teach you how to be an editor.’’
The Press died in 1992 but their partnership did not end. After Mr. McEachran returned to the Memphis Commercial Appeal in 1994, he hired Mr. Sanford as deputy managing editor. Mr. McEachran resigned as that newspaper’s editor and president in 2002, and Mr. Sanford was promoted to managing editor the same year.
Tom Birdsong, a southern West Virginia native who called him “Uncle Angus’’ because they were among the few in town with a southern accent, said Mr. McEachran didn’t care how smart you were “but you’d better work to the utmost of your ability.’’ If you did that, you were in good stead with him, whether you were an editor or a janitor.
Mr. McEachran returned loyalty. When a Press reporter was stricken with Lou Gehrig’s Disease in the late 1980s, Mr. McEachran kept him on the payroll, saying he must have mislaid the corporate paperwork Scripps-Howard sent. When another staffer was desperately ill with cancer and Mr. McEachran heard he’d not signed the proper forms to provide his family the most benefits, he drove to the hospital and presented the papers to the man at bedside.
“For a dying man,’’ Ms. Ross recalled, “he had the strongest signature you could ever imagine.’’
When the Press imploded in 1992, it “about killed him,’’ Mr. McEachran’s daughter, Amanda Simmons LaMountain, said. “It broke his heart, really.’’
In addition to Ms. LaMountain, Mr. McEachran is survived by his son, Angus Gibbons “Gib” McEachran III, and their mother, Ann. He left four grandchildren, Anna Rose and Charlotte “Charlie” LaMountain, Mary Parke McEachran and Angus Gibbons “Gibbs” McEachran IV.
The family asks that donations be sent to the International Center for Journalists.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill
READ MORE: Brian O’Neill: A newsman who knew how to make his point





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.