I’m 12 minutes in when it happens: sleigh bells ringing at the local mall.
Folklore has become reality. Christmas music, in November. Christmas music, 14 days before Thanksgiving. This can’t be real. It just can’t.
But alas, there it is: a holiday jingle coming from a small speaker above the washer and dryer section at JCPenney. And standing under that music is employee John Jamrozik, embedded in a scene of holiday confusion. Since Nov. 1, JCPenney had been playing Christmas tunes every other song.
“We don’t really care for the Christmas music,” he says. “It mentally drains you. You feel overwhelmed.”
It turns out that John would only be the first character in my morning-long investigation into the world of premature Christmas music in the retail industry. And it was certainly the right time for such an important story; a clinical psychologist recently told a news outlet that holiday music too early in the year can be bad for your mental health.
“People working in shops at Christmas have to learn how to tune it out — tune out Christmas music,” psychologist Linda Blair said to Sky News. “Because if they don't, it really does make you unable to focus on anything else. You're simply spending all of your energy trying not to hear what you’re hearing.”
Studies have shown that music impacts our shopping behaviors, and that it is safe for store owners to assume that playing Christmas music earlier will remind shoppers of the holiday and lift their spirits. But was it really true?
So at 10:25 a.m. Thursday I’m greeted by Maroon 5 blaring over the central speakers at Ross Park Mall. Someone should commission a study about Maroon 5’s effect on your mental health, because this is arguably just as bad.
Minutes later, I’m between shelves of “I Sleigh” shirts at Macy’s, where an employee tells me some holiday songs have entered the store’s rotation recently. So I stand under a speaker. And wait. And wait. Two songs pass by. Three songs. Nothing. Is this some sort of sick game? I leave.
I decide to follow a rumor: apparently, Sears started playing Christmas music early in the season. Two songs in, the tip pays off, and I’m fully entranced by Kelly Clarkson’s “Wrapped in Red.” “December comes and goes,” she sings. It’s November.
But the experience reminds me of an employee I met earlier in JCPenney, Barbara Peace. She said some customers have complained about the store’s Christmas spirit. I, too, am on the verge of complaining, but what good would it do? I am but a puppet in a twisted holiday scheme.
Troy, a customer I meet in Bath and Body Works, agrees. He says we should enjoy one holiday at a time. But that’s difficult in Bath and Body, where Christmas music is on a constant, high volume loop. Employees say that on weekends, the sound of customers drowns out the jingles, but not today. “Sleigh Ride” plays loud, followed by a bebop rendition of ... “Sleigh Ride.” I want to help the employees, but there’s nothing I can do. I must help myself.
To get to the bottom of this, I go to talk to mall officials, because one of the only places I haven’t heard Christmas music all day? From the central speaker system.
I ask guest services. The representatives tell me they’re not allowed to speak to reporters. I panic. The Christmas machine must be churning.
And then, it all comes crashing down. As I’m eating a quick lunch in the food court, mall security approaches. I’m being summoned to the management offices. This can’t be good.
I walk down a long, corporate-looking hallway to the manager’s office. There’s no Christmas spirit here. The overwhelming silence makes me long for cheery holiday jingles. Who have I become?
But that was it. During our brief conversation, of which the details I cannot disclose, I come to a realization:
Perhaps, this is a story too dangerous to tell.
Perhaps, Christmas music isn’t to be messed with, and I should leave it be.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.