Allegheny County announced Tuesday that it has signed a 20-year lease to relocate its emergency services department and 911 operations center from Point Breeze to a facility in Moon.

The move immediately drew criticism from Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner, who questioned the transparency of the decision-making process and the choice to move the department out of an urban area.

The county said it will move the department and 911 center to the former US Airways Operations Center owned by the Allegheny County Airport Authority at 150 Hookstown Grade Road. It will take the facilities from a 48,137-square-foot space at their current location at Lexington Technical Park to a 67,390-square-foot space in Moon.

“When we were exploring options for the 911 center to move, it was the one that resonated to us the best because it already had the infrastructure and allows us to enhance our technology,” Allegheny County manager William McKain said at an afternoon news conference.

Advertise with us

The county said it had been renting the space in Point Breeze at an average annual cost of $533,822. The county will lease the new location from the Airport Authority for an annual rent of $1,053,980. Some of the costs will be offset through shared services with the airport, the county said.

The department and call center’s 300 staffers will move over the next 12 to 18 months, the county said. The emergency services department responds to disasters, accidents and security threats.

After the move was announced, Ms. Wagner criticized what she called the lack of openness about the decision to relocate.

“My office’s audit released in May called into question the wisdom of relocating county facilities without a clear rationale or a transparent bidding process,” she said in a statement. “If it is truly necessary to relocate the 911 call center from a facility into which county taxpayers have invested more than $3 million for improvements over the years, a public bidding process should have been conducted to ensure the best deal, as is the policy of other governments and even some private companies.”

Asked whether the county considered competitive bidding, Mr. McKain said that in real estate “it is really difficult to do that” because of the variety of criteria needed for a building.

Advertise with us

“If we were going to move, we had to go to a place that makes sense for us on the services that we provide,” he said.

Brad Korinski, the solicitor for the county controller’s office, said he doesn’t understand why the decision-making process could not have been more transparent.

“I have not heard enunciated the danger from having a bidding process, or having a transparent process,” he said. “There might be a lot of locations that would want you to locate there and may have some good reasons to have you do so.”

Comparing how the county pays for snowblowers to how it pays for real estate, Mr. Korinski said that an open bidding process might have landed the county a better deal.

“We open up the snowblower process because we believe that open bidding results in the best price,” he said. “I think it could be fairly said that open bidding for real estate would do the same.”

Advertise with us

Although the rent at the Moon location is about double, Mr. McKain said that in the long run the county will save money because it won’t need to pay for upgrades to technology and facility maintenance. Matt Brown, county emergency services chief, said the ceiling at the Point Breeze building leaks, and air conditioning units are failing.

“Where we’re presently at needs significant amount of dollars to make the improvements that we need,” Mr. McKain said. “Our equipment is at the end of its useful life, we’re going to be bringing new technology into [the new] facility. That building really isn’t equipped for that.

“In addition, there’s still 13 communities [in Allegheny County] who we don’t dispatch for. So if we’re ever going to accept them in, we need the capacity to do that.”

The city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority, which owns Lexington Technology Park, said shortly after the county announcement that it would accept proposals to purchase and redevelop the site. Mr. McKain, who knew that the URA planned to sell the site, said “it was a factor” in the decision to relocate, “but probably more compelling was, I wanted a building that was state-of-the-art, that can take the enhanced technologies we have, and also grow our capacity.”

Ms. Wagner also took issue with moving the department and call center “to the outer fringes of the county.” She said she was concerned that many of the department’s employees will face complications commuting to work.

Advertise with us

“We make decisions that are in the best interest for the county as a whole, but, absolutely, there are employees that will be impacted,” Mr. McKain said. “Just like where we’re at now, there were people that travel from all over this county to make it to Point Breeze. Now we’re going out west and people are going to have to make decision on how to get there.”

He said the 12 to 18 months the move is expected to take should give employees time to make arrangements for their commutes.

“We have great county employees, we hope they all join us,” Mr. McKain said. “But any of these decisions I’ve made — I moved the county police, I moved the department of human services, we moved the health department from Oakland to Downtown several years ago — we take that all into consideration. But at the end of the day, I make decisions that I think are in the best interest of Allegheny County.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.