Six candidates are vying for nominations for two vacancies on the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court and each has cross-filed for the Democratic and Republican party in the May 16 primary.
Judges serve a term of 10 years at a current salary of $180,000 in one of four court divisions: civil, criminal, Family and orphan's.
Each candidate responded to a questionnaire from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and here are their responses and their rating by the Allegheny County Bar Association after interviews by its judiciary committee:
JESSICA LYNCH, 50
Hometown: Aspinwall
Family: Husband and 2 children
Education: Franklin & Marshall College 1988; William & Mary Law School 1992
Current Occupation: Attorney; specialty in civil litigation, Family law and employment law.
Bar Association Rating: Not recommended at this time
Campaign Website: www.jessforjudge.com
Why would you be a good judge? My knowledge of and experience with the judicial system, dedication to serving my community, and commitment to ethics make me eager to serve and well-qualified to be judge. I have an unique perspective and broad range of skills useful for decisive resolution of matters. I know the legal system from the ground up, including legal aid, domestic matters and high stakes corporate issues. Public service and volunteer work is a way of life for me as I aim to be a good steward. In every aspect of my life I hold true to high ethics and collaborative listening, with empathy. My skills have been tested, and proven successful, in the corporate legal world and non-profit sectors, where I am known for helping to solve difficult problems and moving us forward positively.
What is your background and how are you qualified? Experienced attorney, trial lawyer, and problem solver. Background in legal aid, pro bono (PFA and custody conciliations), Family law, civil litigation, corporate work, employment law, class actions, immigration and alternative dispute resolution. Demonstrated leadership in community organizations and Boards across all segments and demographics. Maintains high ethical standards, is self-disciplined and decisive action-taker. Repeated recognition from my peers for highest legal ability, professional standards and community contributions.
PATRICK CONNELLY, 49
Hometown: Lawrenceville
Family: wife, Lauren Byrne Connelly
Education: Boston College, B.A. in Economics, 1990; West Virginia University College of Law, J.D. 1994
Current Occupation: Attorney specializing primarily in Civil Litigation.
Bar Association Rating: Highly recommended
Campaign Website: www.ConnellyForJudge.com
Why would you be a good judge? The position that we are running for is that of a trial court judge. I believe that, before you become a trial court judge, you need to have been a trial lawyer, and that is what I have been doing for the past 23 years of my career. I have handled and tried cases in numerous counties throughout Western and Central Pennsylvania. I have been in many courtrooms, and been in front of many different judges. I think that I have learned what works in a courtroom, and what does not work, and would like to apply that knowledge and experience as a judge.
What is your background and how are you qualified? Although I have practiced in all four divisions of the court, my primary background is as a civil litigator. Generally speaking, I represent individuals, corporations, small businesses, municipalities, or any other entity that is involved in some type of civil damage lawsuit. I have handled thousands of cases in my career, and generally handle cases from the initial pleadings stage, though discovery, dispositive motions, trial and appeal. My peers in the bar association have rated me as "highly recommended" for the position of trial court judge, the highest rating available, based on my experience and reputation in the legal community.
MARY McGINLEY, 39
Hometown: Squirrel Hill
Family: Husband, two children
Education: J.D., Duquesne University, 2002; B.A., Pennsylvania State University, 1999
Current Occupation: Attorney at Meyer Unkovic and Scott LLP – specializing in representing families and individuals in estate litigation matters, and companies in contractual and other commercial disputes
Bar Association Rating: Recommended
Campaign Website: www.mcginleyforjudge.com
Why would you be a good judge? Public service was instilled in me at a very young age and continues to be extremely important to me. Becoming a judge is the pinnacle of public service in the legal profession and I would take to heart the important responsibilities that come with administering justice. I believe that I can contribute to the dignity and public perception of the bench. For quite some time, I have been drawn to the judiciary, likely because I believe that my temperament is a fit for the position and because I believe that listening is among my strengths. These attributes are complimented by my legal experience, which is specialized in some respects and broad in others.
What is your background and how are you qualified? I bring both a legal and community perspective to the position. For the past fifteen years, I have regularly practiced in two of the four divisions of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, the Civil and Orphans' Court Divisions. I also practice in other counties, federal courts and before administrative agencies. From this experience, I understand and recognize that the strongest judges are open-minded and analytical. I possess those attributes.
A judge is a public servant. With the experience that I have gained through board service, I am able to identify and bring resolution to problems. I recognize that the people bringing issues to the Court, the litigants, must always come first.
PAULINE M. CALABRESE, 54
Hometown: Penn Hills
Family: Married with 5 children
Education: The Pennsylvania State University, B.A. 1985; Duquesne University School of Law, J.D. 1988
Current Occupation: Attorney with the downtown firm of Notaro & Associates, Family Law
Bar Association Rating: Not recommended at this time
Campaign Website: http://www.calabrese4commonpleas.com
Why would you be a good judge? I would be a good judge because I am uniquely and exceptionally qualified. Specifically, although I have practiced in all four Divisions of the Court of Common Pleas, representing clients in jury and non-jury trials, I am the only candidate for the Court of Common Pleas who has spent her entire career practicing in the Family Division, the Division where new judges are typically placed. I have practiced in both the Adult Section and the Juvenile Section, where I served as a court-appointed attorney. I do not need "on the job training." I will hit the ground running from day one.
What is your background and how are you qualified? Practicing law for over 25 years and in all divisions of the court; served as an intern on the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals; served as the supervising attorney for the Law Clinic at Duquesne University; extensive experience in the Family division, where new judges are typically placed; teach other attorneys Family and estate law through continuing legal Education; served on the faculty of Carlow University, adjunct associate professor CCAC, adjunct faculty; volunteer attorney for Neighborhood Legal Services; served as a court-appointed attorney in Juvenile Court.
DAVID LEE SPURGEON, 46
Hometown: McKeesport
Education: Duquesne University; B.A. 1993; Duquesne University School of Law; Juris Doctor 1996
Current Occupation: Judge, Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas – Family Division; Adjunct Professor of Law - Duquesne University School of Law
Bar Association Rating: Highly recommended
Campaign Website: www.keepjudgespurgeon.com
Why would you be a good judge? Currently serving as a Judge, I am assigned to the Family Division – Juvenile Section with a focus on domestic violence. I am the only candidate that has first-hand knowledge of the responsibilities of the job. In addition to being “Highly Recommended” by the Allegheny County Bar Association, I have a proven track record of public service and judicial decisions that are fair and just. I bring a unique perspective to the bench both professionally and personally. Born and raised in the Mon Valley area, I still live in those communities and I am the only sitting Judge or candidate that brings that diverse perspective and life experience to the court.
What is your background and how are you qualified? I had practiced law for nearly 20 years before being appointed to the bench last year. I spent over 18 years in the District Attorney’s Office as a trial lawyer that prosecuted thousands of cases. As Deputy District Attorney, I supervised the Domestic Violence Unit, Mental Health Court Unit and Veterans’ Court as well as Pittsburgh Municipal Court. I became the first prosecutor to appear in the Family Court and prosecute offenders that violated the Protection From Abuse Orders. My unique professional background with Family violence afforded an easy transition as a judge into the Family Division where I am assigned cases where Family violence is prevalent.
ROSEMARY CHRISTINA CRAWFORD, 53
Hometown: Hampton
Family: Mother of 3 beloved dogs, Aries, Athena, and Zeus
Education: B.A. in Political Science from Rhodes College in 1986; Juris doctor from Georgetown University Law Center in 1989
Current Occupation: Attorney, Mediator, Arbitrator, Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee for the Western District of Pennsylvania
Bar Association Rating: Highly recommended
Campaign Website: rosemarycrawfordforourjudge.com
Why would you be a good judge? I am committed to socio-economic justice and fairness, and have cultural competency, along with a proven judicial temperament, legal ability, and consistent history of community service over decades. “I believe in a fair and impartial court system where age, disability, race, gender, religion, orientation, and income play no role in our access to justice and freedom.” My personal history of being a part of integrating a school due to a Judge’s Order provide me with a unique understanding and compassion for those who are not in a position to care for themselves. I served on the Boards of Neighborhood Legal Services where I also handled Protection from Abuse cases pro bono to help abused individuals, the Pennsylvania Legal Services, and the Greater Pittsburgh Literacy Council, among others.
What is your background and how are you qualified? I am the most experienced candidate with the most active documented history of public service over decades. I am an award winning attorney and the only woman candidate rated highly recommended by the Allegheny County Bar Association based on my preeminence in the law, reputation, and integrity. I have been an attorney for almost 30 years. I spent time as a trial attorney – having served as a misdemeanor prosecutor, then trial attorney for approximately 10 years with different entities including the Department of Justice and prominent law firms, and have served as a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Trustee for approximately 14 years.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.