The estranged husband of a woman who admitted she stole nearly $13 million from North Shore-based Matthews International in the largest embezzlement case on record in Western Pennsylvania has been indicted on federal tax charges in connection with the scheme.
A federal grand jury on Tuesday handed up the case against Gary Edward Mills of Dubois, the husband of Cynthia Mills, 56, of Robinson.
Ms. Mills, who worked as cashier and treasury specialist in Matthews’ Bronze Division, waived indictment in March and pleaded guilty to charges related to the theft of the money over 16 years.
She was ordered to pay restitution of $12.969 million to Matthews.
Federal prosecutors also moved to seize a boat, cars, properties, jewelry, furs and other items that she and her husband had bought with the stolen money.
Mr. Mills, a former UPS driver, had been named in her case as joint owner of properties and bank accounts but not charged until now.
Read More
The grand jury indicted him on three counts of filing false income tax returns for the years 2012, 2013 and 2014 in that he did not report stolen income on the couple’s joint returns.
Mr. Mills had not yet retained an attorney as of Wednesday.
His wife’s lawyer, Phillip DiLucente, previously would not say whether his client had been cooperating against her husband or anyone else. She had been charged by a direct complaint called an information rather than an indictment, usually an indication that someone has cut a deal with prosecutors to provide information against someone else.
Mr. DiLucente declined comment Wednesday.
Cynthia Mills’ plea deal with the U.S. attorney’s office calls for her to serve seven-and-a-half years in federal prison for crimes committed between 1999 and May 2015.
Prosecutors said she was responsible for depositing checks and recording transactions into the general ledger at Matthews, a conglomerate best known for making funeral products.
She siphoned off the money from the company systematically and moved funds into a bank account she created for a shell company called Designs by Cindy, then doctored Matthews’ invoices and bank statements to cover her tracks.
Matthews would not comment Wednesday beyond a statement it released when Ms. Mills was charged in which the company said it had cooperated with the IRS and U.S. postal inspectors, who led the investigation.
It’s still not clear how the theft of so much money could have gone undetected for so many years. But the company first disclosed the crime when it said in a third-quarter financial report in July 2015 that a former employee was suspected of stealing $14 million.
The U.S. attorney’s office said the couple spent lavishly on luxury items and also used the money to gamble, although details of those forays have not been released.
Mr. Mills remains free on a $10,000 bond pending his appearance in U.S. District Court on May 25.
The U.S. attorney’s office declined to comment on the case.
Listing of properties and items forfeited as proceeds of stolen money:




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.