The Carnegie Museum of Art made an unusual announcement Friday morning to news outlets and social media.

In a new collaboration with Sarris Candies, it said it would begin selling on Saturday a 12-ounce, Sarris chocolate and pretzel version of one of its most famous sculptures, Alberto Giacometti’s “Walking Man I.” It would be sold in its museum shop and at Sarris headquarters in Canonsburg.

It seemed like a great idea to Janet Ocel.

“I love Sarris candy, and I love the museum,” Ms. Ocel, a retired teacher and principal who lives in Pittsburgh, said in an interview after she posted an enthusiastic comment to the museum’s Facebook page. “It’s a great idea.”

Advertise with us

She was not alone.

Hundreds of others “liked” or shared the idea on Facebook and offered supporting comments, and multiple Pittsburgh news outlets called the museum and Sarris to find out more about this edible art product dubbed “Chocometti.”

But it appears just about everyone neglected to remember what Saturday’s date would be — April 1 — or read to the bottom of the museum’s online post, which read: “(April Fools)” The formal press release emailed to media outlets did not include that last notation.

“What? This is a joke?” Ms. Ocel said laughing, after a reporter told her about the gag. “That is clever. But I still think it’s a good idea.”

It’s just the latest — and very convincing — April’s Fools prank that the museum has been pulling off for the last four years at a time when companies such as Pittsburgh-based American Eagle Outfitters also has drawn widespread publicity on these annual spoofs.

Advertise with us

The Oakland museum went to great lengths to make its prank appear legit. The press release described using 3-D scanners to create a digital mold of the sculpture before translating the rendering to a flat chocolate mold. “The sculpture is a masterwork of force and movement. Plus, those long lumpy limbs already look like chocolate-covered pretzels,” its chief curator, Catherine Evans, said in the release.

The museum used photoshopping to create a believable image of a half-opened box of the new treats (72 percent dark chocolate!), and made sure to involve Sarris directly, getting its permission to use its famous logo, and to quote owner Bill Sarris.

Mr. Sarris was himself a bit taken in by the gag.

The museum “talked to our staff here and they asked me if it was OK that I was in it, and I said, ‘Sure,’ ” Mr. Sarris said Friday. “I didn’t know it was going to be an April Fools’ joke and I’d be getting 20 phone calls about it.”

Jonathan Gaugler, museum spokesman who also seems to be the chief comedian behind the gags, said Mr. Sarris and Ms. Ocel weren’t the only ones initially taken in.

Advertise with us

“At least one news outlet — I won’t say which one — had a crew ready to come out here to see the chocolates until I told them,” he said, chuckling.

And at least one online site, Upgruv.com, a local lifestyles website aimed at young professionals, reported the contents of the press release verbatim as a serious story.

For last year’s April Fool’s prank, the museum announced it was letting Pittsburghers use the museum’s fine art chairs to hold parking spaces; in 2015 it produced a video about WQED’s Rick Sebak getting a formal sculpture of himself done in the Greek style; and in 2014 it had art aficionados chuckling about finding zombies during some restoration work in one of its classic paintings from the 1800s.

Mr. Gaugler said the ideas come up through “banter in the office” and the main goal is to “be as goofy as we can.”

But not every April Fools’ Day gag hits a homerun.

Advertise with us

American Eagle Outfitters learned that last year when it tried to make people laugh by putting an April Fools’ Day video together saying that its Aerie line, which makes undergarments for girls and women, was going to have a line celebrating the diverse kinds of men’s bodies. People did not think it was very funny.

But in 2014 it put out a similar video talking about creating a line of American Eagle-themed clothes for dogs. Viewers not only thought it was hilarious, they thought it was a good idea and the company pursued a line of “American Beagle” clothing.

Something similar might be in store for the “Walking Man I” chocolate-and-pretzel bar.

Mr. Sarris said after he understood what the museum was talking about, “I told them we could do it if they really wanted one.”

Making 12-ounce chocolate replicas of the sculpture? “No. Lifesize,” he said of the nearly 6-foot tall “Walking Man” sculpture, which has been in the Carnegie collection since 1961. “It would probably weigh a couple hundred pounds. But we can’t do it a month before Easter” which is among Sarris’ busiest times of the year.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gaugler didn’t know about Mr. Sarris’ offer until told by a reporter.

On Friday afternoon Mr. Gaugler posted a notice on social media acknowledging the April Fool’s joke and then sent Mr. Sarris a note thanking him: “I told him that after Easter dies down, we’ll have to talk.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill