The Hare Krishna community outside Moundsville, W.Va., signed leases in 2010 and 2014 to sell the shale gas under its properties, but Tuesday the community filed a federal lawsuit challenging an eminent domain action that would result in a pipeline on their sacred land.

The lawsuit says Rover Pipeline LLC’s proposed pipeline route is an infringement on its freedom of religion rights and “seeks to take a non-metaphorical bulldozer through the Vrindaban Parties’ property, and in turn, through their most sincerely held holy sites.”

The lawsuit, filed by Eco-Vrindaban Inc. and Iskcon New Vrindaban, part of the Krishna community called New Vrindaban, seeks to block Rover’s legal request for immediate access and possession of the pipeline pathway through two Krishna-owned properties. It was filed in U.S. District Court in Wheeling. A hearing is scheduled for 10 a.m. Thursday.

Energy Transfer Partners, the same company that is building the 1,200-mile Dakota Access Pipeline, wants to build the 713-mile Rover Pipeline to carry shale gas from Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Ohio into Michigan and Ontario, Canada.

Advertise with us

Gabriel Fried, an executive agent and board member in the Krishna community, said the company’s proposed pipeline route would cut through properties that hold two of the community’s seven sacred temples.

“These are sacrosanct properties,” Mr. Fried said. “Our goal is to protect these properties. We’re not trying to stop the pipeline or progress. We’re amenable to finding a route we and the company can be happy with.”

Two members of the New Vrindaban community leave a cow barn to return to a temple for early morning worship. (Julia Rendleman / Post-Gazette/Post-Gazette)

Vicki Granado, an Energy Transfer spokeswoman, declined to comment on the lawsuit or whether any other eminent domain actions for the Rover Pipeline had been challenged on religious grounds.

Construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline in North Dakota resulted in legal challenges by the Standing Rock Sioux, who claim the pipeline beneath the Missouri River near the tribe’s reservation risked its water supply, traversed cultural sites and impeded its religious practices.

On the two Krishna-owned properties, the company wants to build the pipeline on a permanent 50-foot-wide right of way about 3,000 feet long. Energy Transfer has offered the property owners $7,000.

Advertise with us

The 26-page lawsuit says that although the community has signed leases to sell the gas under its properties as part of a master plan, those leases do not allow for any surface disturbances. And although that plan defines certain areas where drilling and pipeline activity may occur, it “blocks off other sacred areas from any outside intrusion.”

Energy Transfer received a permit from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission on Feb. 3 that allows it to begin construction and also file eminent domain lawsuits against property owners who don’t want the pipeline on or through their properties. More than a dozen property owners in Washington County in Pennsylvania were subject to the eminent domain lawsuit filed last month by the company.

The Krishna lawsuit, filed by attorney Thomas Butz of the Washington County firm Smith Butz LLC, states that Rover cannot meet the legal burden of demonstrating a compelling governmental interest for siting the pipeline through New Vrindaban’s holy grounds.

Based on Hindu teachings and texts, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, or “ISKCON,” was started in 1965 in New York City. The 200-member settlement in West Virginia was established in 1968 as a sacred and spiritual community “known worldwide for cow protection, simple living, holy pilgrimage, spiritual education and loving Krishna,” according to the lawsuit.

“Rover’s proposed pipeline easements would desecrate the New Vrindaban holy sites and steal sacred pilgrimage areas,” the lawsuit says.

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.