A Minnesota prosecutor said Wednesday that the mystery man from his state charged in connection with a 25-year-old slaying of an elderly widow in Indiana County "was in our county for a very short period of time. We had no significant contact with him."

“I don't know the extent of how long he was here,” Jeffrey Haubrich, the assistant county attorney for Rock County, said today. "I had no dealings with him...no contact with him."

Indiana County District Attorney Patrick Dougherty and the Pennsylvania State Police announced Tuesday that an unnamed 61-year-old man from Magnolia, Minn. was in custody and had been charged in the 1991 shooting death of Myrtle McGill, 76, a widow from White Township.

Authorities were stumped for a quarter-century. But that apparently changed, though Indiana County authorities have refused to release more information about the arrest, the suspect or the case until Friday, saying the paperwork is under seal.

Advertise with us

Mr. Haubrich said he learned of the arrest Tuesday when it was reported in the media. The Rock County sheriff contacted authorities in Indiana County to get more information, according to Mr. Haubrich. He said he did not know the name of the man who was charged, though the sheriff might.

Sheriff Evan Verbrugge could not be reached for comment.

“He's not here. We have nothing to do with this,” Mr. Haubrich said. “You're calling me about a guy I know nothing about.”

Rock County sits at the southwest corner of Minnesota and borders South Dakota and Iowa. Magnolia, which runs along Interstate 90, has roughly 200 people.

CNN and the Minneapolis Star-Tribune both produced stories indicating that residents of the town wondered and worried whether a killer had been walking among them.

Advertise with us

“Someone in the tiny southwestern Minnesota town of Magnolia could be a killer. But nobody seems to know who,” the Star-Tribune wrote Tuesday. “The community is waiting to learn which of its 200 residents is suspected in a 25-year-old homicide.”

One resident of the town told CNN, "We're kind of curious to see if it's someone who might have gone to school with him."

For his part, Mr. Haubrich said news of the arrest has riled people.

“The problem is there’s sort of some nebulous news of somebody out there and it doesn't really say anything about who he is or if he’s in custody," Mr. Haubrich said. “The sheriff’s office fielded a significant number of inquires.”

Asked how he felt about the way Indiana County authorities handled the situation, Mr. Haubrich said, “A courtesy call would have been appreciated.”

jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.