BELLEFONTE, Pa. — Penn State attorneys accused Mike McQueary of “exploiting the tragedy caused by Jerry Sandusky for financial gain,” as the former assistant football coach asked a Centre County jury Monday to award him more than $4 million in a whistleblower case against the school.

Mr. McQueary, who witnessed Sandusky's 2001 sexual abuse of a young boy in a campus shower, claims the university defamed him and took away his job after he emerged as the central witness in the case against three school administrators accused of covering up the crime.

But in her opening remarks to the jury Monday, university attorney Nancy Conrad blamed Mr. McQueary's inability to find new work on his own shortcomings and questioned his failure to do more on the night 15 years ago to stop the abuse he says he saw.

“McQueary is under fire for not doing anything to stop the alleged rape,” she said. “He was a 28-year-old of good health and strong build, and he simply walked away? McQueary failed to act like a responsible human being.”

Advertise with us

Those pointed attacks kicked off what is expected to be a two-week trial before senior Common Pleas Judge Thomas Gavin of Chester County on a note of palpable hostility — one remarkable for its contrast to the conciliatory posture the university has adopted thus far in nearly all other Sandusky-related legal claims.

Since 2012, the school has paid more than $93 million to 32 Sandusky accusers, acknowledging that the school bears some responsibility to the victims of its former assistant football coach who is currently serving a 30- to 60-year prison sentence for the sexual abuse of 10 adolescent boys.

Mr. McQueary’s suit is the first the university has chosen to fight at trial.

In his opening remarks to the panel of nine women and three men hearing the case, McQueary attorney Elliot Strokoff said university leaders sought to undermine his client’s credibility as a witness in the days that followed Sandusky's November 2011 arrest.

“Their intention was to sweep this under the rug,” he said. “If Mike McQueary folds or collapses, the case against the [administrators] goes away.”

Advertise with us

But underneath the barbs traded across the courtroom Monday were undeniable signs that even five years later, the scandal that shook Penn State to its core still rippled through the lives of its central figures.

As court watchers — including Sandusky's wife, Dottie — filed into the courthouse, they did so under the watchful gaze of a cardboard cut-out of former Penn State head football coach Joe Paterno propped up outside of a storefront across the street.

Several of those called as early witnesses in the whistleblower case — including Jonelle Eshbach, the first prosecutor assigned to the Sandusky case, and Wendell V. Courtney, Penn State's former general counsel — played prominent roles in the initial investigation.

As for Mr. McQueary, Mr. Strokoff told jurors that his client has been unable to escape the ire of diehard Penn State loyalists who blame him for Paterno’s firing in the midst of the scandal.

He has been unable to find work in the world of college athletics and has earned less than $10,000 in the years since Penn State chose not to renew his employment contract, the attorney said.

Advertise with us

By now, the broad strokes of Mr. McQueary’s story have become a well-worn part of the story of the Sandusky scandal.

It was while working as a graduate assistant under Paterno in 2001 that Mr. McQueary returned to a campus athletics building after hours one night only to walk in on a sexual encounter between Sandusky and a 10- to 12-year-old.

Mr. McQueary did not physically intervene to stop the attack. But he has said he tried to make enough noise to scare off Sandusky.

The next morning, he reported what he saw to Paterno, who in turn informed two Penn State administrators — former athletics director Tim Curley and ex-university vice president Gary Schultz. Neither passed on Mr. McQueary's report to police or child welfare investigators.

State prosecutors approached Mr. McQueary about the incident nearly a decade later after receiving a tip that he had information pertinent to their investigation of Sandusky’s abuse of other young boys.

Advertise with us

His cooperation led to Sandusky’s arrest in 2011, Paterno’s ouster and the prosecution of Mr. Curley, Mr. Schultz and former university president Graham B. Spanier, who are awaiting trial on child endangerment charges.

But it also prompted the decision by university officials to place him on paid leave during the tumult that gripped the campus in the days after Sandusky's arrest. They later chose not to renew his contract when it expired in June 2012.

In his lawsuit, Mr. McQueary claims that decision was an act of retaliation for his cooperation with the investigation.

His lawyers also have alleged that Mr. Spanier defamed him in a statement he released expressing support for his colleagues and calling the allegations against them groundless.

Penn State notes the statement did not mention Mr. McQueary by name and contends it only contained Mr. Spanier’s opinions on the case.

Advertise with us

As for Mr. McQueary's job, Ms. Conrad, the university lawyer, argued Monday that his dismissal had nothing to do with his cooperation with investigators. Instead, she said, it came as part of a housecleaning in the coaching staff undertaken by Bill O’Brien, the head coach hired after Paterno's ouster.

Testimony in the trial is expected to resume today.