Finding that a Cameroonian woman seeking custody of her niece failed to prove that her home would serve the best interest of the child, an Allegheny County Common Pleas judge has awarded custody of the 6-year-old to her Penn Hills foster mother.
Judge Guido DeAngelis wrote in his 64-page opinion issued June 29 that the foster mother, Deborah Cutrary, has had custody of the child since July 2012 and that the girl has a secure attachment to her.
“She is the person who has tenderly, patiently and daily cared for her when she was traumatized, scared and withdrawn,” he wrote. “The foster mother has been the stalwart of stability in the subject child’s life and the subject child has established close emotional ties with the foster mother and with her family.”
Ms. Cutrary filed an adoption petition for the child two years ago, but the process was put on hold when the girl’s maternal aunt, Catherine Gana, arrived in the United States on July 9, 2014, also seeking to adopt her.
Ms. Gana, a school teacher in Bamenda, Cameroon, had previously obtained custody of the girl’s two brothers in Westmoreland County years earlier over a few-month period and expected to go through a process similar to that when she got to Allegheny County. However, what she found was a lengthy, drawn-out process that included 16 trial dates spread over an entire year beginning in February 2015. At the conclusion of the testimony, Judge DeAngelis asked the parties to submit their final briefs by May 20.
Attorneys for Allegheny County’s Children, Youth & Families, as well as KidsVoice, argued to Judge DeAngelis that Ms. Gana did not respond promptly to requests for her to travel to the United States, that the child is already strongly bonded to her foster mother and that removing the child after such a long time could cause lasting damage.
Read More
Ms. Gana, who previously had two attorneys working on the case but represented herself by the end, argued that she came to the United States when she thought she was needed and that she can provide her niece with her family, her history.
Judge DeAngelis disagreed.
“Apparently, [Ms. Gana] held expectations that this court would just give the subject child to her when she arrived and that they would live happily ever after,” the judge wrote. Instead, he quoted the psychologist he appointed to evaluate the parties, who said that “ ‘it would be extremely disruptive psychologically to remove the subject child from the foster mother’s primary care at this time, given the subject child’s secure attachment with the foster mother and given the subject child’s long history of insecurity in placement and permanency.’ ”
Ms. Gana was angry at the opinion.
“I believe the trial given to me was a mockery of the system,” she said.
More than that, Ms. Gana, who also has four sons in Cameroon, is frustrated that the trial took so long.
If Ms. Gana wants to appeal, notice must be filed within 30 days. An appeal will likely languish for months at the state Superior Court, and in the meantime, she has not returned to Cameroon in West Africa since she arrived in the U.S.
Throughout his opinion, Judge DeAngelis repeatedly questioned Ms. Gana’s initial efforts to unite with the child, writing that “as an intelligent and educated woman [she] should have recognized the possible cultural and legal differences between her expectations and the realities of this subject child’s permanency and should have attempted to reconcile those differences by obtaining counsel in making her arrival much sooner rather than at the twelfth hour to the scheduled adoption.”
Then, he turned and used her long stay in Pittsburgh to fight for custody of her niece against her.
“As much as the court recognizes that [Ms. Gana] has demonstrated a commitment to adopt the subject child, there is a clear distinction between manifestations of interest as opposed to affirmative actions taken. The Court maintains reservation about the fact that [Ms. Gana] has balanced her commitment to the subject child against the two biological siblings of the subject child whom she has taken custody of and maintains a custodial obligation to, but yet has been away from them for over two years through the course of these proceedings.”
Among the issues Ms. Gana and her attorneys focused on at trial were a number of inconsistencies they found in the CYF process moving the case to adoption. They included Ms. Cutrary’s adult son who was convicted of attempted homicide and is a lifetime Megan’s Law offender. Although he does not live in the house, Charles Cutrary does visit regularly, including spending time with the little girl. Ms. Cutrary is also raising Charles’ son.
CYF caseworkers testified that they did not know the charges Charles Cutrary was convicted of, and that further they were not relevant to their investigation. They said that they do not do background checks of anyone who does not live in the house.
Judge DeAngelis, in his opinion, said that was fine, mentioning in a footnote that the state legislature has directed agencies to only consider the criminal records of family members who live in the home, despite outside experts recommending that anyone who visits the house regularly be checked.
In addition, Ms. Gana elicited from the CYF caseworkers that they failed to check three of four of the references provided by Ms. Cutrary in her adoption petition. Judge DeAngelis did not mention that in his opinion and instead praised the caseworkers, calling their testimony “credible, historical, reliable, insightful and internally consistent supported by the overall record.” He said that the caseworkers “conscientiously took the actions required, were resourceful and provided guidance to [Ms. Gana.]”
He also said that CYF “made reasonable efforts to the extent that the circumstances and [Ms. Gana’s] actions permitted for consideration of [her] as a reliable adoptive resource.”
Throughout Ms. Gana’s presentation of evidence, she called a number of witnesses who testified that they believed that her niece would be better served by being placed with a biological relative — particularly given that she would also be residing with her brothers.
However, Judge DeAngelis wrote in his opinion that “Simply because a relative has been permitted to intervene in an adoption matter to present his or her own petition, does not mean that the relative automatically prevails on his or her adoption petition.
“This Court does not mitigate the importance of kinship generally or as a social institution,” he wrote, acknowledging kinship preference in public policy and by legislative dictate. But, he continued, the law “does not accept such a preference to be tantamount or over-riding to a child’s best interest.
“The testimony and evidence reveals that [Ms. Gana’s] priorities and understanding of best interest are misplaced.”
Judge DeAngelis continued that the evidence presented by Ms. Gana “creates a number of uncertainties” and then questioned Ms. Gana as being “either naive, unreasonable or lack an understanding,” that she believed she could quickly develop a relationship with her niece since she had done the same for her two nephews in Westmoreland County.
In his opinion, Judge DeAngelis notes that his own court-appointed psychologist, to whom he “afforded a great deal of weight” in making his final decision, recommended that the child be permitted to visit with Ms. Gana. Still, the judge dismisses the idea.
“Respectfully, these recommendations are not of much concern to the court nor are they to be afforded any weight ...” he wrote.
Ms. Gana, who raised questions about possible bias against her throughout the trial, said she still does not know what she wants to do and whether she will appeal.
“They’re robbing a child of her heritage and her family,” she said. “I have wept about it. We are all grieving. It is like a funeral.”
She said she is praying about her decision.
“Right now, my heart and spirit are waiting on the Lord.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.