On Thursday, news broke that a crash that killed a former Murrysville man on a Florida highway had been caused by the malfunction of driverless vehicle technology.
Both the cameras and radar that Tesla uses in its Model S, failed to brake the car before its roof was sheared off in a May collision with a truck.
While the technology used in the Tesla is fundamentally different than the kind being employed by Carnegie Mellon University and Uber in Lawrenceville labs, the incident still raises questions about how to regulate safety during the seemingly breakneck drive towards technological progress.
Officials at PennDOT are hoping to avoid a repeat of the accident as self-driving vehicles, known as SDVs, arrive onto Pennsylvanian roads. As driverless cars become more common, there will have to be several changes to current laws to accommodate a mixed-traffic future and make sure commuters are protected.
Experts across the nation are quickly attempting to tackle these issues by creating the skeletons for future policy, attempting not to be left behind by a technology that’s rapidly progressing.
“There was no way we could pass a law and promulgate regulations, because by the time we could get regulations through the process for approval, the technology would have far outstripped whatever we had written, because it is changing so rapidly,” said Kurt Myers, deputy secretary for Driver and Vehicle Services at PennDOT. “It is literally changing on a monthly basis. ... So the determination was made … that we really need to address this through policy.”
Read More
That’s why PennDOT has formed the Autonoumous Vehicle Testing Policy Task Force, of which Mr. Myers is a co-chair, to analyze and create policies and guidelines to adequately balance safety with progress. The Task Force combines several stakeholders, including members of local government, representatives of CMU and Uber, members of the insurance industry, state police and even AAA, to aid PennDOT in this goal.
“We tried to bring a good cross-section of individuals together, with varying positions as well as views on the subject of autonomous vehicles,” said Mr. Myers.
The Task Force’s most recent work has focused on drafting a bill that has been introduced in the state Senate. The objective of the legislation is to make the guidelines more clear for car manufacturers and tech companies that want to test their SDVs in Pennsylvania. Essentially, the seven-page document stipulates that each company must enter a contract with PennDOT before testing and report all malfunctions of their technology on Pennsylvanian roads.
Despite the risks, PennDOT officials say they are glad to welcome SDVs to their roads. Officials hope that when companies come to Pennsylvania to test these products, they’ll bring high-quality jobs and technology with them.
The legislation is meant to address the emerging issues and also “to say Pennsylvania is ‘open for business.’ Come work with us, we want to help improve this technology and further it,” said Mark Kopko, a senior civil engineer with PennDOT.
Mr. Kopko also believes that Pennsylvania is uniquely situated for companies to test their vehicles. Unlike California, where Uber, Google and many of the tech firms are located, Pennsylvania offers a wide range of geography and weather that would help push these cars and their sensors into the extreme situations needed to gauge their effectiveness.
“We have four seasons, we have hills, we have mountains, we have tunnels. We have twisty-turny roads, we have bridges that were designed back in the revolutionary era, so there [are] definitely some challenges that you have in Pennsylvania that have similarities to other states, and there is some stuff that [is] unique,” said Mr. Kopko.
Officials at PennDOT are also concerned about how the vehicle code will have to adapt to accommodate the influx of SDVs. Licensing, intoxication laws and liability are all aspects of the legal code that may need to be re-examined in the context of self-driving vehicles.
“Most motor vehicle crashes are based on traditional concepts of negligence, and that’s how damages are pursued,” said Bob Shea, senior deputy chief council of PennDOT. “As we evolve towards driverless vehicles, I think there is definitely going to be a shift towards more product liability type litigation and theories of responsibility.”
How the licensing process works to operate autonomous vehicles is another area which will need to be addressed soon. One of the hailed benefits of this technology is that it allows people who couldn’t previously drive equal access to transportation, yet current regulations could still prevent them from operating the machine.
“If you are a quadriplegic, or of an advanced age, and couldn’t possibly qualify for a driver’s license, in theory you would still be able to access an autonomous vehicle and be transported,” said Jason Sharp, executive deputy chief counsel for PennDOT. “So are you going to need a driver’s license to ride in one of these vehicles, even if there is no operator? So how do we license operators will have to be looked at real closely.”
Much of this question revolves around the role of the human in the SDV. Currently, the person in the driver’s seat is responsible for the vehicle and regulations in some states, including the proposed legislation in Pennsylvania, stipulate that a human must be able to take control of the machine in case of a malfunction. Some experts, however, don’t believe that this could be a long-term, sustainable model.
“The technology itself is much faster than a human,” said Frank Douma, director of the State and Local Policy Institute in Minnesota, and an expert in the field. “So it’s a little bit of a fallacy to me that the human would be the fail safe because once the car realizes it’s in trouble, it’s too late for the human to take over, even in the best of situations.”
Yet some officials look to the tragic death of Joshua Brown, 40, formerly of Murrysville, in Florida, as a warning of what could happen when drivers become lulled into a false sense of security. According to unofficial accounts, the driver may have been watching a movie when the accident occurred.
It’s important to note, however, that the technology for sale at the moment, such as Tesla’s “autopilot” feature, is not the same thing as a fully autonomous vehicle, which CMU and Uber are working on. And while it might be a natural urge to let one's guard down, until we completely finish handing over the wheel to computers, it is still a good idea to look at the road.
Jonathan Sundby: jsundby@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.