For one girl, the priest allegedly began years of sexual abuse by fondling and forcibly kissing her at her First Communion party in the 1970s, when she was 7 or 8.
For her sister, it began after he gained her trust through leading a series of children’s activities, then eventually started molesting her in his car during outings and in the church rectory and choir loft.
But until this year, neither knew the other had been abused, according to their attorney. That changed when they began talking about a March 1 report by a state grand jury outlining decades of sexual abuse and cover-up in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown by dozens of priests and others associated with the church.
Tuesday, the two Altoona women filed suit against the diocese, alleging three church bishops allowed a known child predator to work for decades in parishes, right up to the start of this year.
The lawsuits, filed in Blair County Common Pleas Court, allege that the Rev. Charles F. Bodziak repeatedly sexually abused the two girls while they were attending his parish, St. Leo in Altoona, and that he plied them with alcohol.
The plaintiffs, Renee A. Rice and Cheryl Haun, agreed to use their names publicly because they “feel so strongly about what’s happened and what’s not happened,” said their attorney, Richard Serbin of Altoona. Father Bodziak has not faced any criminal charges.
Read More
Mr. Serbin said he hopes the lawsuits influence ongoing debate over legislation in Harrisburg to lift the statutes of limitations on lawsuits over decades-old offenses, a measure vigorously opposed by Catholic bishops who see the potential avalanche of lawsuits as potentially bankrupting dioceses. Mr. Serbin said in this case, the time limits should not apply because of decades of cover-up.
“If it took until 2016 for a grand jury to come forward and publicly confirm what has been going on in the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown, how can two young people or even adults have any hope of having the information to proceed?” Mr. Serbin said.
The lawsuits — the first against the eight-county diocese since the release of the grand jury report — name the diocese, Father Bodziak, retired Bishop Joseph Adamec and the estate of the late Bishop James Hogan as defendants. The plaintiffs seek punitive and other damages on a variety of charges, including the abuse itself and alleged concealment.
Weeks before the grand jury report, Bishop Mark Bartchak cited a past allegation in placing Father Bodziak, 74, on leave.
The grand jury report had given a tentative positive rating to Bishop Bartchak’s responses to abuse while severely criticizing his two predecessors.
Although the lawsuits did not name Bishop Bartchak as a defendant, they accused him of also having left Father Bodziak in the ministry despite evidence in the diocese’s own files. Bishop Bartchak began his tenure in 2011.
In 2003, another woman reported to the diocese that Father Bodziak repeatedly engaged in sex with her when she was 16 years old and in foster care in 1971, according to the grand jury report. At that time, he was a priest at St. Agnes Church in Lock Haven.
Tuesday’s lawsuits alleged the diocese also was notified in 1993 by another victim, and then again in 2006 by Ms. Rice. At that time, Bishop Adamec encouraged her to contact the diocese’s victim’s advocate and review board, but the lawsuit cites the grand jury’s conclusion that this standard process was actually used against victims to protect the diocese from liability.
Father Bodziak was ordained in 1969 and worked at numerous parishes, most recently at St. Michael’s Church in Cambria County from 2010 until January.
The women said Father Bodziak befriended them and other children by taking them out to eat and on other outings.
Each plaintiff said that on numerous occasions, he would reach under their clothes, fondle their breasts and genitals and kiss them while forcing his tongue into their mouths. He told one victim it was OK for a priest to do this, and he repeatedly told the other she was “special,” according to the lawsuits.
The suits said the women suffered severe and lasting emotional harm.
The grand jury report did not result in any criminal charges, mainly because of statutes of limitations that bar prosecutions against decades-old offenses. Jeffrey Johnson, spokesman for the attorney general’s office, said more than 300 people have called the office’s hotline since March 1 and that it is continuing to investigate.
Diocesan spokesman Tony DeGol said he could not comment on the pending litigation.
He said Bishop Bartchak’s placing of Father Bodziak on leave was “a precautionary measure while the diocese re-examines an allegation of sexual misconduct involving minors against Father Bodziak dating back more than 30 years.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.