A small-town parking dispute became a federal case on Tuesday when the American Civil Liberties Union sued an Armstrong County policeman and the district attorney on behalf of a man jailed for recording an encounter with the officer on his cell phone.
It’s the latest in a series of federal complaints brought by the ACLU against police for misapplying the Wiretap Act across the state.
This case began when Michael Gratteri, 50, of Ford City, grew irritated that teachers at Ford City High School kept parking on the street in front of his house, where his disabled wife parked. He said he’d asked them not to park there but they did anyway.
So one day in September 2014, he blocked one of the teachers in with his motorcycle and his car.
The teacher called the Ford City police and Officer Josh Wilford showed up.
Mr. Gratteri used a cell phone clipped on his shirt to record the encounter with the officer and the teacher and said he made it clear that he was making the recording. He also told everyone he had a security camera at his house that was recording.
After about 15 minutes, he ended up moving his bike and letting the teacher drive away.
But a month later Officer Wilford returned to arrest him for violating the Wiretap Act.
Mr. Gratteri had posted the recorded encounter on Facebook. The day after the dispute, Officer Wilford received a text from another cop with a link to the posting. Officer Wilford then contacted the district attorney, Scott Andreassi, who told him he could file the charge, according to the suit.
Officer Wilford hauled Mr. Gratteri to jail in cuffs in front of his son, then 7.
“I went from sitting on my deck with my family one minute to being in handcuffs,” he said in an ACLU statement. “I was in shock. Even though I had done nothing illegal, I was scared that I would not be able to get out of jail.”
His wife bailed him out after about seven hours.
The criminal case went nowhere after that.
“We had a few hearings scheduled and they didn’t show up for them,” Mr. Gratteri said.
The district attorney eventually dropped the charge.
But the ACLU said Mr. Andreassi has incorrectly been advising police that they can file Wiretap Act violations against people who record officers.
Sara Rose, attorney for the ACLU of Pennsylvania, said police seem to need reminders that the First Amendment protects citizens in that situation.
Ford City police said they couldn’t comment. Mr. Andreassi was in trial and did not return a message.
The ACLU has filed multiple lawsuits in the federal courts over similar conduct by police. The most recent local case was in September 2015 when the ACLU sued on behalf of three Oakland residents who said a Pittsburgh policewoman, Elizabeth Vitalbo, verbally abused them, threatened to arrest one of them for trying to record a confrontation and then filed false disorderly conduct charges against them after they complained about her.
The case is pending.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.