Prison inmate Greg Rouzer might consider a polite silence in dealing with his next cellmate.

Seven years ago, after he was jailed on charges of shooting and wounding Randy Walters in rural Fulton County, state troopers said he asked his cellmate whether he knew anyone who would kill Mr. Walters for him.

A trooper posed as the killer and Rouzer ended up pleading no contest in a murder-for-hire plot.

Now police say he confided again in another inmate to try to kill Mr. Walters once more.

Advertise with us

Like last time, the inmate turned informant and Rouzer was ultimately done in by an undercover trooper posing as a go-between using the unlikely moniker “Joanie Pepperoni.”

“It’s a fictitious name that the troopers came up with,” said Pat Dougherty, the district attorney in Indiana County. “There are a lot of other names I would have chosen before that one. It seems made up. But it worked.”

It worked well enough that Rouzer, 48, of Harrisonville, and his girlfriend, Laraine Patterson, 54, of Aliquippa, were charged Monday with conspiring in another murder-for-hire plot after Ms. Patterson met with “Joanie Pepperoni” in Robinson and handed her $1,000 to give to a made-up hitman.

In wired conversations last summer and fall between Rouzer and his cellmate at the Pine Grove State Correctional Institution in Indiana County, troopers said Rouzer indicated he wanted the killing carried out before Christmas to “give himself a birthday present.”

Rouzer is serving 19 to 60 years for shooting Mr. Walters three times in 2008 and then trying to have him killed in 2009 while awaiting trial.

Advertise with us

State police said he also is a suspect in the disappearance of Revell Jeeter of Harrisonville, who hasn’t been seen since 2003 and was declared dead in 2010.

In August, a fellow inmate tipped off police that Rouzer was trying to have Mr. Walters killed again. Troopers wired up the inmate while Rouzer put in motion a plan in which he would “scam his family” out of the money to pay the hitman.

“Ms. Pepperoni” would receive the agreed-upon total of $5,000 from Ms. Patterson for the hit. The two met Jan. 28 in front of the Jo-Ann Fabric and Craft store in Robinson for the first payment of $1,000.

Troopers also said Rouzer indicated he wanted Mr. Walters’ body dumped on the property of another man, James Laughlin, so that police would look at Laughlin for Jeeter’s disappearance.

The connection between Rouzer and Jeeter isn’t clear. He has been missing since July 2003 and state police have said they believe he was killed, but troopers in Hollidaysburg on Wednesday did not return messages seeking comment about why they think Rouzer was involved.

Advertise with us

Rouzer faces a preliminary hearing Friday. Ms. Patterson is jailed in Indiana County on a $75,000 bond and will have a hearing Monday.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.