A judge on Monday threw out part of the federal fraud case against an Oakmont developer, saying prosecutors improperly used the grand jury process and violated the man’s rights.
U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab dismissed counts of bankruptcy fraud and money laundering against Louis Lamanna, 50, of Hulton Road.
He still faces other counts of conspiracy and structuring financial transactions.
The judge made the unusual move because he had dismissed the same counts as part of a plea agreement that Lamanna, a convicted felon, had made with the U.S. Attorney’s office four years ago.
Last Tuesday, the judge again dismissed those counts, which had been included in a new indictment brought in September.
On the same day as that ruling, federal prosecutors filed yet another indictment that once again contained the same dismissed counts, the judge said.
He said the U.S. Attorney’s office had the option of either filing a motion to set aside the original plea agreement or of appealing his ruling to the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals.
Instead, he said, prosecutors chose to file a superseding indictment, meaning Lamanna has been charged three times with the same offenses.
“Such procedure is not an available option,” the judge wrote Monday in throwing out the charges, saying it’s not fair to re-indict someone on counts already dismissed under a plea deal.
The U.S. Attorney’s office would not comment, nor would Lamanna’s lawyer, David Berardinelli, because the case is pending.
But in another court filing Monday afternoon, the U.S. Attorney’s office said it wanted to set the record straight by indicating it did not re-indict Lamanna after the judge’s order last week but had already secured the indictment that day before realizing the judge had ruled.
“Obviously, the timing of events is highly unusual,” wrote Assistant U.S. Attorney Brendan Conway, “but the government believes that it is important that the record reflect that the government did not act in direct contravention of the court’s order as it was not aware of the court’s order at the time it was presenting the superseding indictment to the grand jury.”
Judge Schwab rejected that explanation late Monday, saying the government did contravene him after the ruling in that it ”did nothing on the record to correct this conduct,” requiring him to dismiss the counts.
Federal agents say Lamanna hid his assets from bankruptcy, including bank accounts and a fancy car that he sold. A grand jury said he also conspired with others to structure more than $170,000 in cash withdrawals from two banks to avoid currency transaction reports.
The case began in 2011, when Lamanna was indicted for tax evasion. He was indicted a second time that same year for tax evasion, money laundering and bankruptcy fraud.
He worked out a plea deal in June 2012, but shortly after that the U.S. Attorney’s office filed another case against him, a direct complaint called an “information,” for failure to pay income taxes.
He pleaded to that charge and the parties agreed that the indictment from 2011 would be dismissed at sentencing. He was sentenced in November 2012 to a year in prison and ordered to pay about $708,000 in restitution.
Before he reported to prison, however, he received $345,000. His lawyer won’t say where it came from. But Lamanna didn’t tell the judge or prosecutors about it.
He was in prison for a month when the IRS discovered it, after which prosecutors said failing to reveal the money was a breach of the plea agreement.
Judge Schwab said the government should have filed a motion to that effect.
Instead, the U.S. Attorney’s office filed a new indictment against Lamanna in September that included the same bankruptcy fraud and money-laundering counts that Judge Schwab threw out in 2012.
In dismissing the counts last week, he said allowing the government’s approach in this case would have a “chilling effect on the plea bargaining process” because defendants would face the possibility of seeing charges reinstated without a judge’s oversight.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.