Kirk Nesset

A writer and former Allegheny College professor who said he is mentally ill is headed to federal prison for more than six years after the FBI found 540,000 images of child pornography on his computer.

U.S. District Judge David Cercone on Monday sentenced Kirk Nesset, 58, to 76 months behind bars and an additional 10 years on probation.

He also ordered Nesset to pay $78,900 in restitution under a federal law that requires defendants to pay damages to victims of child pornography identified by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. Several of the children in Nesset’s collection are known victims with restitution claims.

Advertise with us

The U.S. Attorney’s office had asked for a sentence in the advisory range of 151 to 188 months, saying Nesset’s collection of images and videos, including infants being raped, was “horrid.”

But Nesset and his lawyer, Meagan Temple, said he suffered from mental illness and had never touched a child nor had an inclination to molest anyone. Ms. Temple asked for the mandatory minimum of five years, saying Nesset needed treatment, not prison.

“We are very pleased with the sentence and appreciated the judge’s thoughtful deliberation of all the matters presented,” she said.

Nesset, who won the Drue Heinz Literature Prize for 2007 from the University of Pittsburgh Press for his “Paradise Road” short stories, was the target of an FBI undercover operation in Phoenix. He pleaded guilty in April.

“Kirk is not ‘evil’ and is not a ‘bad person,’ ” Ms. Temple said in pre-sentence filings. “He is a tragic figure, actually.”

Advertise with us

Nesset had taught at Allegheny College for 20 years. He resigned after his arrest.

Nesset said he was diagnosed with depression in 1995, started using adult pornography and “migrated” to child pornography. He said his arrest by the FBI and subsequent treatment by a sex offender counselor opened his eyes to the harm he was doing to children.

“With professional help I saw my addiction as illness, disorder and began to realize that viewing what I had viewed contributed to the mental harm abused children suffer,” he wrote.

The U.S. Attorney’s office said Nesset deserved no breaks. Assistant U.S. Attorney Christian Trabold said his collection was carefully cataloged.

“Nesset persistently led a double life, working as a college professor, while concealing his ongoing interest in the sexual abuse of young children,” he said.

Advertise with us

The Nesset case was somewhat unusual for its sheer volume, but otherwise it was not atypical of the many pornography cases seen in the federal courts. The U.S. Attorney’s Crimes Against Children Task Force and other agencies, such as the state attorney general’s Child Predator Unit, deal with these offenders on a daily basis and find that they tend to fit a pattern.

“It’s need-driven. He has it for a purpose,” said Tom Clinton, a retired U.S. postal inspector who for many years was a leader of the Crimes Against Children Task Force in Pittsburgh. “They have thousands of images. People ask, ‘Why do you need more?’ But it’s not about that. It all works on validation. These people need someone else to say to them, ‘I have these same interests. I share the same desires.’ ”

Offenders come from all professions and avenues of life. Cased on the federal court docket include the Catholic priest in Churchill who in 2012 admitted to collecting child pornography and the Monroeville church youth counselor who pleaded guilty last month to possessing one of the largest collections investigators here have ever seen.

Why do these people risk everything they have? Because, the experts say, they can’t control themselves.

“I’ve arrested many a teacher and other people in a professional career who had a lot to lose,” said Mr. Clinton, who now lives in North Carolina. “They have so much at stake. But it doesn’t stop them.”

Advertise with us

A concern for anyone in a community where a pornography collector is arrested is whether that person molested any children. Research indicates a correlation, although the link has long been the subject of debate.

Although some authorities say a third of porn collectors are also molesters, another study of offenders in a North Carolina prison suggests the percentage could be higher than 80 percent.

But Ken Lanning, a former FBI profiler who wrote the analysis many police use in investigating child molesters, said the methodology of the studies is questionable and the true numbers hard to pin down. “Some people molest children, and some people collect pornography, and some people do both,” he said Monday.

For many prosecutors and former agents, there is little distinction.

“They’re pedophiles,” Mr. Clinton said. “This is a person whose sexual preference is for children, whether they act on it or not.”

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.