Iran handed over 25,000 pounds of enriched uranium last month, a key obligation under a nuclear deal struck last summer with the United States and its allies. For the first time in years, experts say, Iran likely lacks sufficient material to make a nuclear bomb.
Not good enough, says U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, who warned Tuesday that lifting sanctions on Iran as part of that deal would be “extremely dangerous.”
Under the terms of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, the Obama administration appears poised to free up some $100 billion of frozen Iranian assets. But the reduction in Iran’s uranium stockpile “doesn’t comfort me very much,” Mr. Toomey told reporters Tuesday. “It’s pretty clear that they are doing the absolute minimum that they need to do to get the money released.”
Mr. Toomey aired those concerns in a Jan. 5 Philadelphia Inquirer opinion piece co-written with former Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Ridge, who headed President George W. Bush’s Department of Homeland Security. Although saying nothing of the uranium transfer, the article cited “egregious offenses” by Iran to argue that “lift[ing] the sanctions is worse than foolish.” Chief among the offenses: a series of Iranian ballistic missile launches, barred by earlier United Nations resolutions, since last fall.
Given such moves, and Iran’s ongoing refusal to admit it ever sought a nuclear bomb, “Why should we consider its actions to be anything other than in bad faith?” the editorial asked.
Mr. Toomey has acknowledged that Congress can’t stop the president from lifting sanctions. But he told reporters that keeping them in place “will certainly be a priority topic” of political discussion.
Mr. Toomey is facing re-election this year, and his campaign lost no time raising the issue against his Democratic challengers. On Monday, the campaign charged that “Joe Sestak and Katie McGinty’s support for the Obama Administration’s reckless nuclear agreement with Iran is looking like an increasingly poor choice.”
The Obama administration initially threatened to sanction Iran after a December missile launch came within 1,500 yards of an aircraft carrier. But the administration later reversed itself, saying it was delaying the move. The Toomey campaign called that shift “feckless,” and Democrats too urged a hard line.
“The Obama administration must act unilaterally or with our European allies to make clear … that violations will not be tolerated,” said Ms. McGinty, a former chief of staff for Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf, in a statement.
Mr. Sestak, a retired admiral who once commanded vessels in the Persian Gulf, called the administration’s shift “inexplicable,” and said it “has to act decisively to impose sanctions” for the launches. But he said he’d leave the nuclear deal itself in place, saying it still offered “a path to ... ending the nuclear program in Iran.”
Missile launches weren’t barred by the nuclear deal, he said, and the United States would lose credibility, and the ability to pressure Iran, if it backed out: “For us not to meet our end [of the bargain] … will harm America’s and Israel’s security.”
Suzanne Maloney, a Brookings Institution foreign policy scholar who studies Iranian politics, agreed.
Iran’s missile launches were a “completely predictable” effort to test U.S. resolve while showing muscle at home, she said. “The administration has to be ready to show toughness, and it’s an open question whether it will do so.”
Still, she added, “what’s key is the Iranians appear to be abiding by the agreement.” Although they were once just months from being able to assemble a bomb, she said, “Now they are a year or more away.”
Given that, Ms. Maloney said, “We can’t play the spoiler” without upending the deal, and leaving the U.S. too isolated to press for continued sanctions.
Braddock Mayor John Fetterman, a third would-be Democratic challenger, offered a simpler reason for sticking with the deal: “I don’t know how many mulligans we’re going to give to Republicans on Middle East policy.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.