Sarah Boehm’s disappearance and subsequent death 21 years ago are still shrouded in mystery, but authorities hope to bring the case to a close.

Sarah was 14 years old when she was last seen by her family in 1994 in their home in Rochester Township. A body was found almost four months later about 75 miles from Beaver County in a wooded area in Ohio but was not identified as Sarah until 2003.

The FBI, working with other investigators, will return next week to the Ohio woods where her body was found and, using modern technology, attempt to find new or previously overlooked evidence that might help them find her killer.

“We have the teams, the training and the technology,” said Gregory D. Nelson, an FBI special agent in charge in Washington, D.C. “I’m confident we do have the ability to find whatever evidence there might be.”

Advertise with us

Sarah was last reported seen by her brother leaving her Rochester home July 14, 1994. She was supposed to be going to a friend’s house on the same street, but she never made it.

Police later discovered that Sarah had never made plans to go to her friend’s house that night and may have been involved with an older man who abused her.

Her remains were found by hunters on Nov. 4, 1994, in woods near Berlin Lake Reservoir in Portage County, Ohio, about 800 yards from the body of another girl, Kathryn Menendez, 17, of Alliance, Ohio. Investigators said they have not been able to connect the two deaths, but they are performing a “parallel investigation.”

When Sarah’s remains were discovered, the hoop earrings she always wore were missing, and hair was found nearby that investigators deemed did not come from Sarah.

With technology that is now available, investigators hope they will be able to locate the earrings, test the DNA of the hair, and possibly find more evidence related to the case.

Advertise with us

Authorities said they have multiple suspects but declined to provide further information about them.

The FBI offices in Pittsburgh and Cleveland as well as local investigators and private groups are assisting in the investigation. The FBI became involved in 2001 because the case covered multiple jurisdictions and crossed state lines.

Authorities said they want to publicize the case because it was originally believed that Sarah was a runaway. And because police believed Sarah had run away, they didn’t enter her disappearance in the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children database.

It wasn’t until the skeletal remains were identified as Sarah’s that her disappearance turned into a homicide investigation.

“In the years in between, it was a missing person’s case,” said Kim Clements, a retired detective from Beaver County who has been involved in the investigation.