Utility task vehicles, off-road vehicles that are like a cross between an ATV and a golf cart, were developed in the early 1980s for outdoor workers.

But more uses were discovered for them over the years, including recreation on private property and racing.

The number of reported injuries and deaths in UTV accidents has also climbed over the years.

Two people were killed in separate UTV incidents in southwestern Pennsylvania over the weekend — 12-year-old Marrius L. Duncan of Adrian and Robert S. Basinger, 50, of Connellsville. The two fatalities added to a list that includes at least a dozen statewide since 2003.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, a debate has raged between the UTV manufacturing industry and the federal government over what safety features the vehicles should be required to have. Utility terrain vehicles, recreational off-highway vehicles and side-by-sides come with many guidelines and recommendations, though certain safety features are not mandated, such as side doors.

The driver and passengers are supposed to wear seat belts and a helmet at all times. Some do not. That, combined with the lack of side doors, can result in a death if the passenger is ejected and the vehicle, weighing anywhere from 900 to 1,500 pounds, lands on them.

UTV manufactures have fought against requiring side doors or additional safety features besides helmets and seat belts.

“What they believe in is driver training,” said Clarence Ditlow, executive director of Washington, D.C.-based Center for Auto Safety.

Driver training, though, is not mandated, either. It is offered by manufacturers, which will pay for the training and provide incentives to take it, such as giving out gift cards.

Advertise with us

According to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, at least 550 UTV incidents with an injury or fatality were reported in the Unites States between Jan. 1, 2003, and April 5, 2013, including 12 in Pennsylvania. The number of incidents in the U.S. that resulted in at least one death or injury jumped from 63 in 2011 to 88 in 2012, the last full year statistics are available. The most in one year in the U.S. was 101 in 2007.

Many deaths result from rollovers, which should be prevented by safety equipment, including a canopy above the passengers. Officials said that Mr. Basinger, who was killed Saturday night when his vehicle flipped onto its side after he sped through the River’s Edge Campground park and onto Adelaide Road, was not wearing a seat belt or helmet.

Marrius, who was among four juveniles riding with an adult driver, was wearing a helmet but still died in an accident.

Gary Harper of Crossroads Motorsports, a UTV retailer in West Deer, said he has experienced rollover crashes during training sessions, and he has been able to climb out uninjured, like others who follow safety protocols. He said most UTV crashes are the result of driver error and injuries are a result of people not following safety procedures.

Mr. Harper said that driving a UTV is like driving any other vehicle and requires competence and responsibility.

Advertise with us

“These are not toys in any way,” he said. “When bad things happen, people blame the vehicle itself when there is a laundry list of human error that is possible.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.