A federal judge’s ruling last month roiled the immigration world, but in the end, it didn’t matter one bit.

As a result, an illegal immigrant from Honduras is headed back there without much fuss.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab on Thursday sentenced Elionardo Juarez-Escobar, 42, to time served, which is about six months since his arrest in July, and ordered him turned over to immigration authorities to be deported.

The judge made national headlines last month in the otherwise routine case when he ruled that President Barack Obama’s immigration policy violates the Constitution.

Advertise with us

Mr. Obama issued an executive order in November that will benefit millions of illegal immigrants who have been in the United States for more than five years but whose children are citizens or permanent residents. The policy would allow those people to seek relief from deportation and obtain work permits.

The judge ruled Dec. 16 in the Juarez-Escobar case that the policy is against the law and gave him a chance to withdraw his plea or receive a sentence of a year of probation so he could stay in the United States and fight deportation. After being arrested on a charge of drunken driving in April in New Sewickley, he was taken into custody in July and pleaded guilty to the federal charge in October.

Instead of fighting, he chose to be sentenced and deported.

Because of that decision, the Justice Department said the judge’s ruling is moot and chose not to challenge it. Prosecutors had argued from the beginning that the president’s Nov. 20 order does not apply to criminal cases.

Juarez-Escobar’s case was no different from any other alien re-entry case until Judge Schwab made the unusual move to seek input from attorneys on both sides Nov. 24 and then made his ruling.

Advertise with us

He gave Juarez-Escobar a last chance to change his mind Thursday, saying he might have an argument to stay because his mother is a permanent resident and his brother is a U.S. citizen, as are his brother’s four children.

But Juarez-Escobar reiterated through an interpreter that he wanted to be deported.

His lawyer, Alonzo Burney, said he appreciated the chance to address the immigration issue and had brought in an immigration lawyer to help him with the case, although in the end it didn’t change anything.

“We thank the court that we had that opportunity,” he told the judge.