A lawyer for a Mexican man charged with entering the U.S. illegally said Sunday a federal judge's ruling last month that President Barack Obama's immigration policy violates the constitution has no bearing on his client's case because it's a criminal matter and should proceed as such.
Writing on behalf of Marco Garcia-Caseras, 31, who has been in custody since his arrest for public drunkenness in Moon in October, attorney Michael Healey said U.S. District Judge Arthur J. Schwab "should not be addressing issues raised in the [president's orders] in any criminal case in that they do not apply to criminal cases."
Judge Schwab had ruled that Mr. Obama violated the law when he issued executive orders in November delaying deportation for millions of illegal aliens.
The judge made that ruling in the case of Elionardo Juarez-Escobar, 42, a Honduran man who pleaded guilty to illegally re-entering the country. But in two other similar cases, one of them the prosecution of Mr. Garcia-Caseras, the judge also asked lawyers to weigh in on whether the president's executive order would have an impact.
While not necessarily improper, many legal observers and the Department of Justice saw the move as an attempt by the judge to influence immigration policy when he has no business doing so, especially in routine criminal cases before him.
In all three cases, federal prosecutors said the president's order does not apply because they are criminal prosecutions in which the men had been deported and then sneaked back into the country.
Read More
Mr. Healey agreed and said his client plans to plead guilty, as almost all of those charged with illegal re-entry do in federal courts across the nation. He said Mr. Garcia-Caseras is willing to enter his plea next week.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.