Allegheny County Council will hold a public hearing this afternoon on a proposed system for posting A-B-C cleanliness grades on restaurant doors.

The grading plan, supported by county Executive Rich Fitzgerald and opposed by some local restaurant owners, was passed by the county’s Board of Health in September and referred to council’s health and human services committee for debate a month later. A vote is expected early next year.

Scheduled to speak today are Andrew Szefi, county solicitor, and Karen Hacker, health department director. They, respectively, are likely to address criticisms of the proposal, including that it violates state law and would not improve food safety.

In a Nov. 6 letter, state Rep. John Maher, R-Upper St. Clair, told Dr. Hacker the ordinance would require a change in state law. A day earlier, the health department addressed in emails to council eight “misconceptions” and “misrepresentations” about the grading plan, which it contends is legal.

Advertise with us

Restaurateurs also have complained that grades based on annual inspections are unfair because they represent only a snapshot in time. The health department has said that the public expects that restaurants use safe food handling and sanitation practices “at all times.”

In the first year, restaurants would have a chance to improve a grade lower than “A” before it is posted. In future years, the grade will be posted and then the restaurant can be reinspected to improve the grade.

In late August, several restaurant owners were invited to what Councilwoman Sue Means, R-Bethel Park, described as an informational meeting she hosted with members of council’s Republican caucus. A representative from the Pennsylvania Restaurant and Lodging Association and a couple of Democratic council members who happened upon the assembly also attended.

Also scheduled to speak today are John Longstreet, president and CEO of the PRLA; J. David Piposzar, adjunct assistant professor of environmental and occupational health at the University of Pittsburgh; and Christopher Hickey, New York City regional director, New York State Restaurant Association. A question-and-answer session and public comment will follow.

The hearing is set for 4 p.m. in the Allegheny County Courthouse’s Gold Room, Downtown. Council is expected to vote on the plan early next year.