It took 16 months of detective work before investigators were ready to announce a suspect in the slaying of a Mercer County businessman who was stabbed 76 times in his home, but it’s still not case closed.

After charging a female prison inmate with Frank Crash’s murder, prosecutors are still investigating a mysterious male person of interest whom District Attorney Robert Kochems has mentioned several times since May.

What role, if any, this person played in the crime and his identity are some of the key questions that remain unanswered in a drama that has shocked Hempfield, a rural township of 3,700.

Where is the murder weapon, which police have not found? How many assailants were there? Why was the suspect, Tracy L. Hassel, charged with second- and third-degree murder but not first-degree murder, which applies to an intentional killing, in a case where there were so many wounds, and do investigators still have any interest in various people who were subject to some of the case’s search warrants?

Advertise with us

The wait for answers isn’t easy.

“I know the daughter and the son-in-law real well. They need closure,” said Hempfield Township Supervisor David Geisel, who bought his former concrete business from Mr. Crash in 1970. “They need this thing to come to an end. It’s out there for them until it’s done.”

Pam Higbee, one of Mr. Crash’s children, found her father dead July 25, 2013, inside his home. Investigators sent evidence that might contain the killer’s DNA to the Pennsylvania State Police crime lab for analysis.

About six months later, in January, an informant told police that a man named Steven Mortland “told him that he and his girlfriend, Tracy Hassel, committed the homicide of Frank Crash,” according to a search warrant affidavit.

The allegation was intriguing, and with good reason. The snitch “was told information that was not released to the public and described some information that only a person who was involved would know,” the affidavit said.

Advertise with us

Investigators swiftly ruled out Mortland as a suspect. He had a perfect alibi: Records show he was in the Allegheny County Jail during the four-hour window the county coroner established for Mr. Crash’s death.

Mortland told police the same thing as the informant: that Hassel was involved in the homicide. The men’s stories diverged, however, when it came to who else was allegedly there.

Mortland said it wasn’t he but another man whom he and Hassel knew.

Mortland told police that Hassel and the man had accompanied him to Pittsburgh the day of the homicide just before Mortland went to jail on an outstanding arrest warrant. After Hassel bailed him out, she told him that she and the man broke into Mr. Crash’s house to steal money but that the victim interrupted them.

Hassel’s companion ran off, Mortland told police. She “pulled her pocket knife out and started stabbing [Mr. Crash],” according to Mortland’s account to police as described in a search warrant affidavit.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette is not identifying the man Mortland said was with Hassel the night of the killing because he has not been charged. Court records show that a man by the same name is a convicted felon with a criminal record in Lawrence and Mercer counties dating to at least 2006.

He has pleaded guilty to drug charges, burglary and criminal trespass. He also pleaded guilty to simple assault for stabbing someone during a fight, according to media accounts at the time.

Is the man the male person of interest? The district attorney isn’t saying.

On May 21, Mr. Kochems said the person of interest left Pennsylvania for the East Coast. A notation in court records at the end of that month shows that the man whom Mortland identified was in Delaware.

Just days earlier, police obtained a search warrant for records back to July 23, 2013, related to cell phones belonging to the man and Hassel.

Advertise with us

“The records requested will help show a direct connection between Hassel and also [the man] during the course of the crimes alleged,” the warrant said.

During a news conference announcing Hassel’s arrest, Mr. Kochems said the person of interest remained under investigation “and we are hopeful with the arrest of Ms. Hassel further information to clarify his status will be developed.”

Efforts to reach the man were unsuccessful.

Even as investigators try to sort out information about the male person of interest, they are convinced of Hassel’s involvement in the homicide. According to court records, their case is built on the following: DNA evidence from the crime scene that allegedly matches Hassel’s; Mortland’s statements; and clothing, a wig and shoes recovered in Pittsburgh that investigators say are linked to the suspect.

Hassel’s attorney, Komron Jon Maknoon, said last week that it was premature to comment because he had not yet met with his client.

Advertise with us

During one of three interviews with police that are documented in the affidavit supporting Hassel’s arrest, she denied knowing anything about the homicide but acknowledged having been intimate with Mr. Crash, a widower.

The DA has stated “there are no other persons of interest to us at this time” beyond the unidentified male.

With Hassel’s arrest, Mr. Kochems said he hopes that “further information to clarify his status will be developed.”

There are additional areas of inquiry that investigators have pursued but that have not been fully explained by the DA.

One of them involves the curiosity that police exhibited early on about the victim’s other daughter, Susan Brenneman, and her fiance, John W. Rice Sr.

Advertise with us

The day before Mr. Crash’s body was found, an off-duty police officer saw Ms. Brenneman walking toward Mr. Crash’s house. The next day, one of the homicide investigators saw three bandages on her right pinky.

Ms. Brenneman told police that she had cut her hand opening a can. Officers wanted to check. Armed with a search warrant, they went to the couple’s home.

Police spotted what looked like dried blood on the bathroom floor and a light blue shirt, stained with what appeared to be blood, soaking in a chemical, according to a search warrant affidavit.

A list of items seized from the home includes a can of Great Value chicken gravy, four steak knives and a blue towel with blood.

Ms. Brenneman said last week that she felt as if the police suspected her and Mr. Rice of having some kind of involvement in her father’s death. She said neither of them played any role.

Advertise with us

“They tried to say that, but I didn’t have anything to with that and neither did my fiance. My fiance is a good, loving man,” Ms. Brenneman, 50, said. “Neither one of us had anything to do with it.”

Ms. Brenneman said she had cut her hand on a can, which was turned over to police. She also said that her shirt was soaking because she had gotten red hair dye on it – not blood.

Mr. Kochems would not answer any questions about the couple.