Lying unresponsive after a beating, his skull fractured and his brain hemorrhaging, Lewis Campbell III was in such dire shape “we were investigating it like it was a homicide,” California borough police Chief Rich Encapera testified Monday.

“He was not expected to live,” the chief said.

But now, almost three weeks after that Oct. 30 assault, Mr. Campbell, 30 of West Chester, Pa., is out of the hospital. And Monday his girlfriend Shareese Asparagus, 22, also of West Chester, testified during a 2½-hour preliminary hearing after which all six California University of Pennsylvania football players were held for trial on charges that they assaulted Mr. Campbell as he walked outside a restaurant with his girlfriend just off the Cal U campus.

The attack, the latest in a string of incidents involving the football team, rocked the university and attracted national attention. It led Cal U president Geraldine Jones to announce a top-to-bottom review of the football program.

Advertise with us

Five players were held for court after Monday’s preliminary hearings. The sixth, Corey Ford, was ordered held before it since he waived his preliminary, attorney Phil DiLucente said.

The other five players are Jonathan Barlow, D’Andre Dunkley, Rodney Gillin, James Williamson and Shelby Wilkerson.

All six face charges of aggravated assault, reckless endangerment, harassment and conspiracy.

The suspects originally had been held on $500,000 bonds. Some of them had already had that high bond reduced, and Brownsville District Judge Joshua Kanalis on Monday reduced the bonds of the rest of them.

Three of the players remained in jail Monday night — Mr. Barlow, Mr. Gillen and Mr. Ford.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ford’s bond already had been reduced to $15,000 from $500,000, but he remained in jail because of charges he faces related to a car crash in Washington, D.C.

During the hearing, Washington County District Attorney Eugene Vittone presented two videos of the incident, including one captured by a surveillance video camera looking onto Wood Street from a florist shop near Spuds restaurant.

The surveillance video showed several men surrounding a person believed to be Mr. Campbell. Someone shoves him to the ground, and then another person runs up and kicks him squarely in the head.

The assailants then move out of the range of the camera and disappear.

The prosecution and defense offered differing explanations for what triggered the violence depicted in the video. Ms. Asparagus testified she was walking with Mr. Campbell when a man she identified as Mr. Ford said “Hey” to her, followed by a remark she described as disrespectful.

Advertise with us

Pressed during cross-examination to be more specific, she said it was “You look sexy, or something like that.” She said her boyfriend said “Hi to you” back to Mr. Ford to let him know he had heard the comment.

She said Mr. Ford replied that he wasn’t talking to Mr. Campbell but to the woman and used an obscenity. More words were exchanged, and Mr. Campbell was surrounded and beaten, she said.

Defense attorneys noted that Mr. Campbell could have left. They noted Ms. Asparagus’ testimony that she had tried to restrain Mr. Campbell unsuccessfully and painted his actions as aggressive, removing his jacket more than once possibly in preparation for a fight.

Ms. Asparagas said her boyfriend was not brawling.

“It was not a fight. It was a beating,” she said. “It was six to one.”

Advertise with us

The defense asked Cal U police detective Michael Hampe to read a portion of a statement Mr. Wilkinson made the day of his arrest.

In it, Mr. Wilkinson said Mr. Campbell made a racial slur and threatened to kill people. Mr. Wilkinson, in his statement, said Mr. Campbell then said “I’ll kill you.”

Mr. Campbell and the suspects are African-Americans.

The defense said the video and testimony, including that of Chief Encapera, left unclear what exactly transpired and how many of the suspects actually were involved.

The six defendants face formal arraignment Jan. 26 in Washington County Common Pleas Court.