Some remember Christopher Columbus for his bravery as a navigator, explorer and leader. Others, however, remember Columbus for setting off centuries of colonization, oppression and genocide.

These sharply contrasting versions of the Italian adventurer manifest most visibly on Columbus Day.

“It’s a day to celebrate our ancestors,” said Pittsburgh Columbus Day Parade organizer Cathy Costa Fusca.

“When you say you’re honoring Columbus Day, you’re not really honoring Columbus as a person,” said entertainer and activist Phat Man Dee. “You’re honoring the fact that somebody came over and invaded.”

Advertise with us

With the national holiday celebrated on Monday, about 50 protesters took to Downtown streets for a march organized by local social justice group Pittsburgh for Justice to decry Columbus and urge the city to rename the holiday “Indigenous People’s Day.” The movement is not limited to Pittsburgh and city councils in Minneapolis and Seattle among others have voted to instead celebrate “Indigenous People’s Day.”

But there are those who want to continue to celebrate Columbus Day, like Mrs. Costa Fusca, who has helped organize the Pittsburgh Columbus Day parade for 29 years.

The parade is not just for Italians, though. Mrs. Costa Fusca invites all nationalities and religions represented in Pittsburgh to participate in the parade. She even asked the Council of Three Rivers American Indian Center one year, but the council said it would never participate.

The council doesn’t protest the parade either, although Executive Director Russell Simms said the organization does not approve of the holiday. He said that the group has to pick its battles and a more positive result can come from educating people rather than protesting.

“Self-satisfaction comes out of protesting,” he said, “but how permanent is it?”

Advertise with us

There is also controversy as to whether Columbus was as vicious as his detractors make him out to be. Some have opined that rumors about his deplorable behavior were started by Francisco de Bobadilla, who wanted to take Columbus’ place as governor of Hispanola, according to an opinion piece on the Fox News website by Tommy de Seno, a conservative blogger.

Miguel Sague Jr., a Taino, which is a native group from Cuba, was at the protest and wanted to debunk that the idea that Columbus may not have been as bad as believed.

“What [Columbus] wrote with his own hands indicate very clearly what his own intentions were in sailing west,” he said. “His intention was to become rich, to become a very wealthy man. He never claimed he was doing anything for human kind. He never claimed that he was going to discover a new world.”