A consultant hired by Pittsburgh to review policies and practices governing outside employment by police officers in the wake of revelations that the former chief had helped organize a private security business is nearly done with his report.

Steven M. Toprani, the former Washington County district attorney, said Monday that his report should be complete by the end of the month and will be provided to Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and city council.

"I recognize that city government will ultimately decide whether or not reforms are necessary. My purpose is to give them a guiding document," Mr. Toprani said. "I want to give them the tools they need to go forward."

Mr. Toprani declined to reveal the specific conclusions of his research or any recommendations.

Advertise with us

He did say, though, that he reviewed the outside employment practices of 15 to 20 cities, including Boston, Washington, D.C., Detroit, San Jose and Los Angeles.

While many cities have reformed their policies on an issue that has been "on the national radar" for a decade, Mr. Toprani said, "Pittsburgh, surprisingly, has not."

The city hired Mr. Toprani in April for $10,000 to review the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police's policies on outside employment, or work that is not managed by the police bureau but would potentially come into conflict with it.

That is separate from so-called "secondary employment" -- moonlighting coordinated through the police bureau's special events office.

In February, Mr. Ravenstahl announced that Mr. Toprani would look into the issue after the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported that former police chief Nate Harper had organized a private security venture with four subordinates in the department.

Advertise with us

That was followed by the revelation that one of those subordinates, Cmdr. Eric Holmes, had worked for a year both as a full-time city police sergeant and the head of Slippery Rock University's police force.

Cmdr. Holmes remains under internal investigation about his second job, an arrangement the mayor has called "unacceptable."

"Principally we're looking at matters that either utilize or give the appearance of utilizing law enforcement policies, methods, equipment, authority," Mr. Toprani said.

"Private security, obviously, is the most direct example, and that will be featured prominently," he added. "I don't think the city necessarily has an interest in curtailing its officers owning a mom-and-pop pizza store."