Kim Pirilla-Scalise runs a company delivering government-subsidized home care services for frail individuals to help them stay out of nursing homes.

After June 1, when the Corbett administration plans a rate reduction for home service providers in seven southwestern Pennsylvania counties -- a cut unequaled anywhere else in the state --Ms. Pirilla-Scalise says her Superior Home Care and dozens more agencies are going to need to consider giving up their government-funded clients.

In Allegheny County, Superior would be receiving at least $5 an hour less than it does now when its personal care aides visit residences to do housekeeping, bathe clients, prepare meals or perform any number of additional services.

"This is nothing short of a catastrophe," said Ms. Pirilla-Scalise. "For those of our consumers who are vulnerable [if] remaining at home without home care services, the only viable option they will have available is nursing home placement."

Advertise with us

That concern is shared by some of the local government officials, like Area Agency on Aging directors, responsible for delivering assistance to the needy elderly or younger people with physical disabilities.

Both puzzlement and alarm have pervaded much of the region's home care industry since April 20, when Bonnie Rose, deputy secretary of the state's Office of Long-Term Living, issued a memo to the care providers and local government agencies they deal with. She advised them of a new rate structure planned for six programs providing in-home care to more than 20,000 frail older adults and nearly that many disabled individuals younger than 60.

Under the rates intended to take effect next month, providers in Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Fayette, Greene, Washington and Westmoreland counties would receive $17.16 an hour, less money than those in the three other regions of the state for delivering personal care services -- nearly $2 an hour less than peers in Philadelphia and its suburbs and in rural, northern tier counties.

Those varying rates cover reimbursements for what are known as "waiver" home services. As opposed to other older adult services funded by the Pennsylvania Lottery, the waiver services are paid out of the Medical Assistance budgets of the state and federal governments.

The Aging Waiver, Attendant Care Waiver, Independence Waiver, COMMCARE waiver, OBRA waiver and Act 150 programs are linked by the fact they're all geared to serve people whose modest income and frail health would make them eligible for Medical Assistance funding of nursing home care, if that's what they chose.

Advertise with us

Since most people would rather live at home, and paying for in-home care typically costs the state and federal governments less than half of what they would have to pay to nursing homes, the waiver programs have grown in recent years. The state provides them by approval of the federal Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services.

Department of Public Welfare officials say it was CMS that demanded a new rate structure providing more consistency, because currently providers are reimbursed differently from one another in almost every county and even within counties. Most of some 50 agencies delivering personal care aging waiver services for nearly 1,200 Allegheny County residents do so for more than $17.16 an hour now, and some receive as much as $24 hourly.

While the new plan is designed to be revenue neutral rather than cutting costs overall, the effect of a $17.16 hourly payment would be a reduction for most providers in the southwest. Agencies in Philadelphia (to be paid $19.12 an hour) would both be paid better than they are now and more than counterparts here, and that also would be true in many non-urban parts of Pennsylvania (to be reimbursed $17.96 or $19.08 an hour in the two other regions).

The difference is baffling to officials locally, particularly in that the basis for the different rates has only been offered in vague terms by state officials.

"The rationale or explanation has not been provided," said Margaret Morrison, administrator of Allegheny County's Area Agency on Aging. She has requested supporting information from the Department of Public Welfare, as has the Pennsylvania Homecare Association through a formal Freedom of Information Act request.

Advertise with us

Ms. Morrison said she started hearing concerns about the new rates from providers soon after the April 20 memo. Some have told her they could not financially cover the services at $17.16 an hour and would discontinue them, and her counterparts in other counties have heard the same thing. The rate is supposed to cover not only the aide's wages, which represent more than half the reimbursement, but also the employee's benefits and the employer's taxes, insurance, administrative salaries, office overhead and other expenses.

Ms. Morrison is worried about finding new providers to pick up services for any clients who lose the agency that has traditionally served them.

"This is kind of overwhelming us at the moment," Ms. Morrison said, after meeting with about 30 providers last week. "On a scale of 1 to 10 [of concern], I'm like at 11. ... We estimate that about 25 percent of these clients have some level of dementia, so the last thing you want" is disruption in who is visiting their home.

Leslie Grenfell, executive director of the Southwestern Pennsylvania Area Agency on Aging, which covers Washington, Fayette and Greene counties, believes, as does Ms. Morrison, that the local providers' financial concerns seem legitimate. That's even though providers in her counties have traditionally received less than those in Allegheny.

She and others are puzzled not just that local rates would be lower than those in the rest of the state, but that rural Greene County's rates would be equal to urban Allegheny County. Also, the rate structure compensates local providers more than anywhere else in the state if they send nurses to homes to deliver more specialized in-home health services -- the exact opposite of the disparity for personal care, which is the bulk of the work.

Advertise with us

Department of Public Welfare spokeswoman Anne Bale commented to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette by email on the changes, saying: "The new rates were based on a market analysis of the state to flush out the unique factors specific to each part of the state. The market analysis included an analysis of Pennsylvania's economic rate, regional salaries and a county-by-county profile."

She said she did not have more specific information to provide on why the southwest region had the lowest rate in the state for some services and highest for others. She said state officials do not expect the changes to result in a greater need for nursing home use by clients.

"Consumers first and foremost need to be aware that nothing in these regulations will change the way they access and enroll in services," Ms. Bale wrote. "Additionally there are thousands of providers across the state who will be able to continue to offer these important services."

The state and federal governments are to spend more than $875 million on the affected programs in the new fiscal year, but Ms. Bale said the rate-setting is by regulation outside of the state budget process. It is not subject to legislative scrutiny, although some lawmakers lobbied by the providers in recent weeks have written to the governor's office objecting to the rates and seeking more information about them.

"This rate reduction would spell business closures, loss of jobs, an increase in nursing home admissions and, consequently, higher costs to the state and its taxpayers in the long run," wrote state Rep. Timothy Solobay, D-Canonsburg.

Advertise with us

Ms. Pirilla-Scalise said she and other providers understand that they can't all be paid the same relatively high Allegheny County rates as in the past, which has been $22.20 for Superior. But they at least expect something more in line with the rest of the state, not significantly lower.

The Welfare Department is awaiting approval from the federal CMS administrators before putting out the new rates for a formal public comment period and officially setting them. But if that happens, Ms. Pirilla-Scalise suggested, providers will need to scale back and focus instead on the private-pay clients who are also part of their business.

"There will be pretty much a mass exodus of every [local] provider out of the waiver programs," she predicted.