Years before Winston Churchill memorably spoke of the “special relationship” between the United Kingdom and the United States, he told a Pittsburgh audience that the two nations had a common role to play in keeping the world prosperous and at peace.
One key was maintaining a strong military. “Of course, the English-speaking people of the world are all in favor of disarmament, of peace between the nations,” Churchill said to a crowd of 1,000.
He spoke at Oakland’s Carnegie Music Hall on March 7, 1932, during his only visit to Pittsburgh. “But how tragic it would be, if, after a protracted program of disarmament, we were to learn that the English-speaking peoples were the only ones so anxious about peace.”
His speech was covered in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on March 8.
He spoke in Pittsburgh nine months before Adolf Hitler became German chancellor. The Nazi leader soon embarked on an arms buildup and war policy that by 1941 had united America and Britain in a common defense of Western values.
During most of World War II, Churchill served as Britain’s prime minister. After the war, he used the phrase “special relationship” in several speeches, including his “Iron Curtain” address at Fulton, Mo., in 1946.
Churchill was one of many visitors to Pittsburgh who, over the decades, helped heal the rifts created by two early wars between the United States and Great Britain. Those historic links between southwestern Pennsylvania and the U.K. are at the heart of the first-ever “Britsburgh” celebration that begins Tuesday and continues for seven days.
When Churchill visited the city as part of a lecture tour, he was no longer in government. He was widely known as a prolific writer and knowledgeable commentator, but he was also seen by many as a washed-up politician. His 1932 stop in Pittsburgh brought him to the city named for one of his most distinguished predecessors in Parliament: William Pitt the Elder.
Gen. John Forbes named the settlement at the forks of the Ohio for Pitt, who directed the British government during much of the French & Indian War. Arriving here in November 1758 at the head of a combined British and Colonial force, Gen. Forbes drove the French from what would become Pittsburgh’s Point.
The success of Gen. Forbes in capturing the ruins of Fort Duquesne, however, may have marked the high point of British-Colonial and later British-American cooperation for the next 150 years.
Tense times
Relations between American colonists and the mother country already had begun going south in 1755 when another British general, Edward Braddock, had been trounced by a combined French and Indian force. After Gen. Braddock was defeated only about 7 miles east of the Point, settlers complained that the Pennsylvania frontier had been left without defenses. Things got worse after 1763 when King George III declared that lands west of the Allegheny should be closed to more Colonial settlers.
The American Revolution permanently split the mother country from its colonies. Even after that war formally ended in 1783, the threat of renewed violence remained. The British had failed to withdraw from forts in the Ohio Country claimed by the United States. In response, Congress had “come to a determination of raising troops for the purpose of taking the western forts withheld by the British,” The Pittsburgh Gazette reported in its Aug. 26, 1786, edition. While the dispute dragged on for another 10 years, it ultimately was settled peacefully.
The two countries, nevertheless, were once again at war in 1812. The fledgling U.S. still hoped to conquer British Canada, but that effort failed disastrously, but not until Canadian and U.S. cities — including Washington, D.C. — were burned. That conflict effectively ended in a draw with bad feelings all around.
British-American relations remained cool at best. The situation was not helped by events like the 1842 visit by 30-year-old Charles Dickens, already Britain’s most popular novelist. The author was impressed by Western Pennsylvania scenery but not by the “ugly confusion” of smoky Pittsburgh.
As North and South headed closer to Civil War — mostly over the issue of slavery — Great Britain saw its interests aligning more with the Southern states. That region provided cotton for British mills, and its wealthy planters were consumers of British manufactured goods.
Royal visits
That made for frosty feelings between the two-largest English-speaking nations. However, in 1860, a young man’s visit to Pittsburgh helped warm up that relationship.
The identity of the 18-year-old Englishman traveling to the United States under the title Baron Renfrew was a badly kept secret.
The “baron” had been christened Albert Edward at Windsor Castle shortly after his birth in 1841 to Queen Victoria. He was Prince of Wales and heir to the British throne. Pittsburgh was one of his stops 155 years ago on an unofficial tour of North America. He arrived Oct. 1, 1860, at Allegheny City’s railroad depot on what is now Pittsburgh’s North Side.
He was the first member of the royal family to visit the former British colonies, and the Daily Pittsburgh Gazette reported that he made a favorable impression.
He stayed overnight in the city’s finest hotel, the Monongahela House on Smithfield Street. The next morning he traveled by open coach to the Pennsylvania Railroad station, giving residents plenty of opportunity to observe him, but not get too close. As he left the hotel, a cavalry escort from the Duquesne Greys militia and Young’s Brass Band, “defiling on each side of the carriage, formed an escort of honor to the Prince and checked the inconsiderate curiosity of the crowd.”
“As the cortege passed along the streets, it is needless to say the Baron Renfrew was the person upon whom all attention centered,” a reporter for the Gazette wrote on Oct. 3. “The ladies in particular smiled benignly on him and waved their handkerchiefs, and he invariably responded to their attentions by bowing and lifting his hat.”
“His face did not indicate a great amount of intellectuality nor the want of it,” according to the paper. “His features were good, with a little cast of the German in them, and his person was graceful.”
The reporter also seemed struck by his ordinariness. “He … looked much like other young men brought up in good society, and there was nothing about him to indicate he is the heir apparent of the English throne.”
Pittsburgh would have to wait 128 years for another visit by a Prince of Wales. In March 1988, Prince Charles, the son of Queen Elizabeth and current heir to the throne, was the keynote speaker at a Remaking Cities conference.
He arrived during a late winter snowstorm. By the time his limousine reached Downtown, the city’s celebrated view at the end of the Fort Pitt Tunnel was lost in a blinding blizzard, the Post-Gazette reported.
While Pittsburghers were disappointed that Charles had not brought along his wife, Diana, the heir-apparent generally charmed the people he met with during his overnight stay in Pittsburgh.
‘Red Coats’ return
Even more so than visits by princes, an event that took place less than a year before the start of World War I helped to usher in a new era in British-American relations.
That was when British officers came to southwestern Pennsylvania to honor one of their own: the doomed Gen. Edward Braddock. Gen. Braddock had been wounded on July 9, 1755, during a battle in what would become the borough named for him. The unlucky general died July 13, about 7 miles southeast of present-day Uniontown, and was buried in an unmarked grave.
On Oct. 15, 1913, Fayette County residents, state officials and members of Braddock’s old regiment, the Coldstream Guards, gathered to dedicate a granite monument and bronze plaque to his memory. Gen. Braddock’s remains had been reburied there in 1804.
About 1,000 people met the noon train carrying British officers when it arrived at Uniontown’s Pennsylvania Station, according to the next day’s edition of the Pittsburgh Gazette. Correspondent George A. Campsey reported that someone in the crowd yelled, “The Red Coats are coming” as the train pulled in.
The new monument had been erected along Route 40 in what was called Braddock Memorial Park. Getting there from Uniontown required a hike or slow ride up Chestnut Ridge, and the Gazette’s reporter wrote that some people had started out for the afternoon ceremony as early as 5 a.m. “Many entire families took a holiday to attend the dedicatory exercises and the park took the form of a sort of picnic ground early in the day,” he wrote. About 5,000 people made the trek.
Former Secretary of State Philander Knox, the main speaker, scored points with the British contingent when he assured them the U.S. no longer had any designs on Canada.
Lt. Gen. Sir Alfred Edward Codrington, a former colonel in the Coldstream Guards, talked about the common history, common language and similar flags of the United Kingdom and the United States. “It is indeed a happy omen that we have here today flags — of different nations — yet you see in them the same red, white and blue,” he told the crowd.
The outdoor program was followed by a banquet for 125 guests at the nearby Summit Inn, which still is in operation along Route 40. The multiple toasts offered at the dinner included one from Pennsylvania Gov. John K. Tener that summed up the tone of the day’s events: “At Peace with the Mother Country.”
By the time Churchill arrived in Pittsburgh in 1932, the U.S. and the U.K. had fought as allies in World War I. There was, nevertheless, still suspicion among many Americans, especially Irish-Americans, about “perfidious Albion.”
Concerns about Churchill’s security meant that he would “be constantly accompanied by a police escort from the time he arrives at the Pittsburgh & Lake Erie depot early today until he leaves Pittsburgh after he lectures in Carnegie Music hall tonight,” the Post-Gazette reported on March 7, 1932. “The guard was deemed advisable to protect him from cranks.”
In addition to warning about the dangers of too many defense cuts, Churchill talked about ways the U.S. and Britain could together fight the worldwide depression, according to a March 8 story in the PG. Moving to another issue, he opined that high taxes, rather than prohibition, offered a better way to deal with alcohol abuse.
Both Britain and the United States had much they could learn from each in terms of improving their economies and governments, he told a reporter for the Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph. Such advice, however, was unlikely to be followed. “But English-speaking people are apt to be obstinate,” Churchill said in a story that appeared March 8. “Tell them to go one way and they are certain to go the other.”
Len Barcousky: lbarcousky@post-gazette.com or 724-772-0184. Len will discuss British visitors to Pittsburgh at a Britsburgh Afternoon Tea at 3 p.m. Wednesday at the Mansions on Fifth. Call 412-381-5105 for reservations.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.