A motion to release a consultant’s report on the Ross Township police department failed Monday when it did not get a second.

Ross paid police consultant Ronald Smeal $31,800 in Nov. 2020 to study police operations. Residents have asked commissioners at the last three meetings to release the report to the public.

Commissioner Chris Eyster motioned for the report to be released but did not get a second.

The township previously lost an open records appeal filed by residents, but appealed that decision to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.

Advertise with us

“You’re making the township look bad. This is crazy,” said resident Frank Colucci. “Please open it up. Think about your constituents and what they want.”

Eric Ticjak said that not releasing the report “just smacks of some kind of cover-up.

“This gives a bit of a black eye to Ross Township. I don’t think there is any hiding from that,” he said.

Commission President Dan DeMarco, who last month addressed some of the issues found in the report, said commissioners offered Mr. Colucci and others the opportunity to read the report. Instead, he said, the residents “went on social media. That’s ridiculous. It’s absurd.”

He said reports on township operations are “no different than contract negotiations,” which are done in private.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeMarco said the report does not make any recommendations on personnel, just operations.

“The board has directed the police department to work together regularly to address the issues based on the third-party recommendations,” he said. “As a lawyer, I am very disappointed in how this had all panned out in the past few months.”

Commissioner Bill McKellar, chair of the public safety committee and a retired law enforcement officer, met with Chief Joseph Ley and the Ross Township Police Association more than 20 times in 18 months to help resolve conflicts before Mr. Smeal was hired.

On Monday, Mr. McKellar said he believes that the report should remain confidential. “The report was for the board of commissioners to evaluate,” he said.

In other action, the board approved the transfer of a liquor license from Pittsburgh for the new BJ’s Wholesale Club at The Block Northway.

Advertise with us

Ryan Yetton, who will be the store’s manager, said there will be a “beer garden and eatery” in the club and beer and wine will be sold to non-members.

The board also approved an ordinance adopting a fee of $150 per year for each hydrant that is privately owned. The hydrants must also be inspected annually and proof of the inspection must be provided to the township. Some private hydrants have been unable to be used for a fire because they were no longer functioning.

Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.